What Really Happened to J. Krishnamurti?

By Bill Keidan

Recently, after visiting the Alpheus Web site, I felt moved to revisit a task which I attempted whilst editing a local Theosophical magazine some years ago viz. to help bring a contrarian critique back into the Krishnamurti debate, which had become somewhat censorious along the lines of “let no dog bark but me.” Speaking from my own belief, I feel it actually does harm to Theosophy to encourage unproven systems of philosophy to run without asking to see the beneficial results in the lives of their promulgators; and the regrettable evidence from Radha Sloss’s book was that Krishnamurti did not feel obligated to practice what he preached–not perhaps something remarkable in a person of the work-a-day world–but pretty devastating in the case of someone who had accepted the mantle of a world philosopher. I hope by sharing my thoughts and researches it may in a small way help Theosophy to move on into the 21st Century.

Much of what I have to say comes either directly or indirectly from Geoffrey Hodson, a leading Theosophical writer, lecturer and thinker of the last fifty years. As my destiny would have it, in 1973 I came to reside in the same building as Geoffrey and his wife Sandra during their stay in Perth, Western Australia. And it became possible to visit them at that time on almost a daily basis for approximately eight months. Even after they returned to New Zealand I subsequently kept in close touch by correspondence for the next ten years until Geoffrey’s death in 1983.

My belief, supported by such evidence as became available to me, was that Geoffrey ‘s childhood was characterized and nurtured by family love, intelligent education and psychological and physical balance. Thus the seed of a psychic and spiritual idiosyncrasy that he was born with was able to take root and grow into a healthy plant in this fertile environment. A more profound development occurred by Geoffrey’s energetic and ethical engagement with life as well as by co-operation with the wider plan for Theosophy through his lectures, writing and service to those in need. Consequently, he matured into an initiated Gnostic seer and eventually, I believe, became a humble mouthpiece for the Masters of the Wisdom to the outer world. He was what, I suppose in Biblical terms, would be called a prophet. But, to adapt another Biblical analogy, he was not a prophet totally accepted in his own country, especially not in the Krishnamurti part of that country. I mention this in detail because if one is going to make an appeal to authority or base one’s belief on an authority, one needs to know the validity upon which that authority is anchored. For example in Govert Schüller’s  very interesting article Krishnamurti and the World Teacher Project several revelations are mentioned, Geoffrey’s included, which are very different from each other. If these are the experts on the subject then, as the old saying has it, “When the experts differ who do you believe?” Before one can assess how much reliability to place in these different opinions it would be helpful to know whether they are based upon such matters as mediumistic communication, intuitive feelings, clairvoyant investigation or direct advice and teaching from a Master of the Wisdom, or a fully developed yogically attuned disciple of the same. I make no claim to any of these insights myself, I am just piecing together some of the information that has come to me from my connection with Geoffrey Hodson over the years plus a little in the way of logical deduction.

What is said in Krishnamurti and the World Teacher Project concerning Geoffrey’s statements on Krishnamurti is accurate as far as it goes. His view may appear to have been changeable, drifting towards the conciliatory, but knowing Geoffrey I would like to suggest that it was more likely to have been stated in oracular language designed to achieve diplomatic co-existence. I suspect that Geoffrey chose to be ambiguous for at least three possible reasons: 1) Because he did not wish to promote a split in the Adept inspired Theosophical Society to which he had dedicated his life, 2) Because his Masters did not want his own important voice on Basic Theosophy, especially The Path Ideal, to be lost during times of transitional ideology within The Theosophical Society, and 3) Since K. was still alive and teaching at that time, he had no wish to hurt him or his followers, especially perhaps in view of the many early and profound sacrifices that K. had made for the work and which was surely one factor in the 1929 separation. What I am suggesting is that Geoffrey actually had a mature view of the situation which he chose not to reveal openly as the time was not yet ready, and the far-ranging research presented in Krishnamurti and the World Teacher Project had actually picked up the tip of that iceberg. But now that both Jiddu Krishnamurti and Geoffrey Hodson have passed over (J.K. d.1986, G.H. d.1983), and what was once private and sensitive information is now arguably repressed energy that should be dissipated for the psychological health of Theosophy, The Theosophical Society and for the sake of the historical record.

Even though Geoffrey as well as others accepted that the overshadowing was always experimental and that the stresses from K.’s upbringing and training had been very great, it was nevertheless his belief that an act of choice occurred within K.’s psyche which made it impossible for the process to continue. The spin that Krishnamurti put on the matter of course implied that he was rejecting something less desirable for something more desirable. It must be left to the consideration of thoughtful readers whether Krishnamurti’s philosophy was a fair exchange for a full-blown teaching mission of The Lord Maitreya Christ. Incidentally in 1973 when I privately asked Geoffrey whether David Anrias’ analysis in Through the Eyes of the Masters was the correct one he denied that was the real reason for what went wrong, and I did not then feel comfortable to press him further as to what actually had happened. It was only many years later that I found out from a friend who received the information from a very close pupil that Geoffrey’s understanding of the situation was as follows.

At a certain stage in the initiation process a pupil has the right to ask a boon from the Master, such a request is normally granted. K asked for the life of his brother Nityananda, who at the time was dying of tuberculosis. Unfortunately, Nityananda had already agreed to endure his terminal illness so that a karmic debt could be cleared in preparation for a fortunate rebirth; in such circumstances the boon could not be granted. Apparently K. could not accept this decision with equanimity and became very antagonistic towards the Masters, resulting in what is so well documented about the change in his direction accompanied by many iconoclastic comments,some even suggesting that the Masters are irrelevant.

In addition, through my own research of Geoffrey’s writings and when I wrote my first article on this matter in October 1995, I realized he had made provision for posterity by seeding information of the actual mechanism of what happened into one of his posthumously published books. Of course the case mentioned does not have K’s name attached to it, therefore it has not been widely canvassed or publicized for what it is, but the context clearly indicates who it refers to. I might also add in passing that there are other revealing comments that could appear to refer to K. in the same book. Let us, however, content ourselves with the main entry that I refer to above:

Reductions of contact with the Master may temporarily occur as a result of two procedures. One of these is interior and almost automatic; for when an Initiate falls deeply into error, indulgence, denial and scorn of the occult Path, his own Ego withdraws its radiant influence and knowledge of the Brotherhood so that the personality forgets about the illumination and upliftment it has received. The other is external and may be regarded as a surgical operation by the Brotherhood which, regretfully and generally for the remainder of that life, closes down the memory centers associated with Occultism in the mental body and even in the brain. In both cases, the psychical and magnetic interplay, which continually occurs between every faithful Initiate and his Master and the Brotherhood as a whole, automatically becomes reduced and eventually ceases. Even so, a certain stamp of princeliness remains and can on occasion be discerned. All such falls, however, are tragic for the Brotherhood and the Master concerned, who must shoulder some responsibility for failure just as He would share in the karma of success. Of course, this applies to the Initiated Ego which has found itself powerless to control the personality and maintain its conscious link with it – chiefly showing as aspiration and determination towards the heights (G. Hodson, The Yogic Ascent to Spiritual Heights, Manila: Stellar Books, 1991, p.191).

Perhaps it was that “certain stamp of princeliness” which remained in K., which made him so charismatic and awe-inspiring to many; perhaps it was partly his ascetic Indian good looks–a significant marketing factor in the modern world; perhaps it was that his very absence of a path seemed an opportunity to break free for some anally retentive people who were captives of their heavy intellectual baggage; perhaps, indeed, amongst some of K.’s strange dismissive answers to questioners and his iconoclastic utterances there are the occasional true insights? Whatever the totality of the answer, one thing is certain: Geoffrey Hodson has supplied us with a Theosophical insider’s inner and occult analysis. In addition, Radha Rajagopal Sloss in her Lives in the Shadow with J Krishnamurti has given us a family insider’s revealing character and personality analysis–intellectually honest because it was written more in sorrow than in anger. It has certainly taken long enough to come to this point, but I am hopeful that some forward movement in the spiritual life of the planet will occur from thoughtful consideration of how we find ourselves taking advice from those whose philosophy is generated more by their own needs than by perennial factors.

If the Krishnamurti business is ever put to bed within The Theosophical Society, maybe room will become available for the Path Ideal to return at the level of intensity it deserves. I trust that my readers will indulge me in quoting an inspiring encouragement along these lines taken from Geoffrey Hodson’s writings:

Arise all you who would attain. Send up your cry for light and enter fearlessly upon the upward Way. It is for you. It calls you. It is your destiny to succeed. Aid awaits you. Your Teacher is near you, watching you. Look not back but forward and you will see His face. Earth’s Supermen wait upon earth’s men, ready to assist each one who answers to the call and with sincerity and whole-heartedness gives himself entirely to the Quest of light and power and truth, aspiring ardently to become a servant and a saviour of the world (Geoffrey Hodson, The Pathway to Perfection. Adyar, 1954, p. x).

[Written by Bill Keidan in 2002 especially for Alpheus]

Krishnamurti and the World Teacher Project: Some Theosophical Perceptions

By Govert Schuller

With the centennial of Krishnamurti’s birth concluded it might be a good idea to present an overview of the different ways he has been perceived in the Theosophical movement.(1) As there is such a wide variety of Theosophical ideas about the person Krishnamurti and his teachings, I propose to limit the scope of this paper to the perceptions of Krishnamurti, which primarily concern themselves with the metaphysical status of Krishnamurti as a spiritual teacher. Those views primarily concerned with the metaphysical importance of his teachings will be left out. It is inevitable, though, to include some quotes dealing with the content of his teachings to clarify the views about Krishnamurti. Having limited the field of inquiry, I propose the thesis that the vast majority of these views can be differentiated according to a matrix determined by the way Theosophists answered two basic questions concerning Krishnamurti.

The first question concerns the expectation of and preparation for the coming of a great spiritual teacher as was announced by Annie Besant, then President of the Theosophical Society. During a lecture at Madras on December 31, 1909, she made the statement that a great “Teacher and Guide….will deign once more to tread our mortal ways.” (2) Together with her colleague and friend Charles W. Leadbeater, Besant propagated the idea that the young Jiddu Krishnamurti would be the vehicle through whom this teacher, the Christ or the Lord Maitreya, would manifest, as he had done two thousand years earlier when he had worked through Jesus of Nazareth during his ministry in Galilee. They then founded the Order of the Star in the East, with Krishnamurti as its head, in order to bring together those who believed in the coming of this teacher. The important question for many Theosophists at the time was, and for some still is: Was this project genuine or not? The term genuine does not necessarily refer to the correctness of how Annie Besant and C. W. Leadbeater perceived and propagated this project, but it refers to whether the project was perceived as having its origin in a transcendental source of supreme intelligence regardless of how it was interpreted by human agents.

The second question was and is perceived by Theosophists as even more important. It concerns the result of this project: Was the outcome of the project successful or not? Here again the term successful does not necessarily refer to the way in which the project was expected to be successful, but rather to the fact that the outcome of the project was perceived as having fulfilled the original intention of the transcendental source of intelligence. The point of this nuance about the meaning of the concepts “genuineness” and “success” is to be able to include viewpoints which do not exactly corroborate, but are close to Besant’s and Leadbeater’s statements about the project.

The possible answers to these two questions generate the four following positions:

1) The project was perceived as genuine and successful;

2) The project was perceived as genuine, but failed;

3) The project was perceived as not genuine and failed (of course); and

4) The project was perceived as not genuine, but succeeded!

The Theosophical commentators and ideas presented in this paper are classified accordingly. This treatment is not exhaustive; many views are excluded. The criteria of selection are: importance of the source, in the sense that the person propagating the view is regarded important as an independent teacher of Theosophical ideas; originality of the view, in the sense that the view helps to open up the complexity and multi-dimensionality of the whole issue; and accessibility of primary sources to avoid erroneous hearsay. (3) In some cases I included Krishnamurti’s own reply to the views put forward.

As position two is taken by many persons it is inevitable to give that relatively more space, as is inversely the case with position four. The view of each person discussed will be presented as much as possible in his or her own words. In the cases where a “Master of Wisdom” or “Adept” is quoted, nothing definite is implied about his ontological status or the veracity of his statements. Krishnamurti’s view of himself is included in this discussion. His view can be seen as belonging to position one.

The article will close with four additional views of Krishnamurti, which are all important from an epistemological perspective. The first two are not rooted in a Theosophical world view but are based on direct observations of Krishnamurti and as such not classifiable in the proposed matrix. They are important, however, because any future Theosophical theory about the metaphysical status of Krishnamurti will have to take these observations into account. They provide building-blocks, yet uncolored by Theosophical concepts, to be incorporated in a Theosophical or psychological theory. The third view is Theosophical and is important because it makes a beginning with putting the two non-Theosophical views in a Theosophical perspective, though not in such a way as to be classifiable according to the matrix. In fact it takes an interesting epistemological meta-position about the matrix in its entirety, as does the last view. These last two views belong to a classification, which encompasses at least three different epistemological attitudes towards metaphysical knowledge. 1) Theosophical: One has access to and knowledge about the metaphysical realm of noumena. Intuition, deep speculative reasoning, clairvoyance and revelation provide us with that access. 2) Agnostic: One acknowledges the possibility of access to and knowledge about the metaphysical realm, but does not have it (yet). 3) Kantian: One can not have access to and knowledge about the metaphysical realm. Knowledge can be attained only about phenomena, not about noumena.

VIEW ONE: THE PROJECT WAS GENUINE AND SUCCESSFUL

Krishnamurti.

Those who have read the second volume of Krishnamurti’s biography by Mary Lutyens (4) will probably remember the extraordinary last two chapters, in which Krishnamurti is questioned by his friends Mary Lutyens and Mary Zimbalist about who he really was, what the “other” was behind him and what “it” was that protected him. Krishnamurti himself stated that he was unable to find that out, because “water can not know what water is.” However he expressed his conviction that if someone else would find out, he could corroborate it. He also stated that “it” was “there, as if it were behind a curtain…I could lift it but I don’t feel it is my business to.”

Even so, Krishnamurti did lift the curtain a little. He admitted that the “Besant-Leadbeater theory of the Lord Maitreya taking over a body especially prepared for his occupation” was the most simple and likely explanation. Krishnamurti did not think this theory was correct, and anything simple was suspect in Krishnamurti’s view. Although he said that Maitreya as explanation “is too concrete, is not subtle enough,” he did consider it the most plausible one.(5) It must be remembered that Krishnamurti never denied being the World-Teacher. In 1931 he told Lady Emily, the mother of Mary Lutyens to whom he was very close, “You know, mum, I have never denied it, I have only said it does not matter who or what I am but that they should examine what I say which does not mean that I have denied being the W.T.” (6)

Krishnamurti revealed to Mary Zimbalist another intriguing indication of his self-perception when he discussed with her in May 1975 his forthcoming biography by Mary Lutyens. She had asked him why the Masters, if they existed, had spoken in the old days, but not recently. “There is no need for them now the Lord is here” was Krishnamurti’s reply. Mary Lutyens did not think it was a serious remark, because of the tone of his voice. (7) The same idea appeared, this time apparently in a serious way, in a dialogue between Krishnamurti and some persons at Brockwood Park, England, in the autumn of 1975, when the subject of his biography came up: “there is the idea that when he [the Bodhisattva] manifests all the others [the Masters] keep quiet.” Is Krishnamurti referring to himself? When reading the whole dialogue that specific question arises irresistibly. The just-quoted sentence was preceded by an elaboration of the idea of the Bodhisattva: “There is a very ancient tradition about the Bodhisattva that there is a state of consciousness, let me put it that way, which is the essence of compassion. And when the world is in chaos that essence of compassion manifests itself. That is the whole idea behind the Avatar and the Bodhisattva. And there are various gradations, initiations, various Masters and so on…” (8) I think Krishnamurti does refer to himself, but he is not doing so explicitly, because for him it was “irrelevant,” though not irrelevant enough not to mention it.

Reinforcing this view is an interesting, and at first sight puzzling, remark Krishnamurti made about Annie Besant and the Theosophical Society during an equally interesting conversation in 1979 with his friends, Radha Burnier and Pupul Jayakar, while discussing Burnier’s possible candidacy for the presidency of the Theosophical Society. “Mrs.Besant intended the land at Adyar [the T.S. international headquarters] to be meant for the teaching. The Theosophical Society has failed, the original purpose is destroyed.” (9) This remark contains many assumptions and finds its proper context in Besant’s understanding of the mission of the Theosophical Society and the role of Krishnamurti therein. Annie Besant thought she was fulfilling a mission of the Theosophical Society, which was not stated as one of its official objectives, but was given to it by Helena P. Blavatsky–one of the founders of the Theosophical Society and the society’s main source of ideas–when she, at the close of her life, announced the coming of a “torch-bearer of Truth” for the later part of the twentieth century. The mission of the Theosophical Society, according to Blavatsky, was to prepare the way for this “new leader” and prepare “the minds of men….for his message.” At his arrival the Theosophical Society would be available to him to remove the “merely mechanical, material obstacles and difficulties from his path.” Indicating the possibility of a glorious long-term goal of this plan, she states that if “the Theosophical Society survives and lives true to its mission…earth will be a heaven in the twenty-first century.” (10) When Besant was challenged about her involvement in the Order of the Star and her speaking of “the T.S. as being the Herald of the coming Teacher,” (11) she defended herself by referring explicitly to Blavatsky’s view about the future mission of the Theosophical Society: “My crime is that I share it, and do what my poor powers permit in preparing the minds of men for that coming.” Besant wrote that the only difference between herself and Blavatsky regarding the coming of “the next great Teacher” was that “she put that event perhaps half a century later than I do. Which of us is right only time can show.” (12)

I think it is reasonable to state that the particulars of Blavatsky’s and Besant’s views were picked up by Krishnamurti during his formative years. He might even have read Blavatsky’s statement referred to above. If so, this might provide the ground to put Krishnamurti’s remark in historical perspective, and to explain the underlying structural similarity between his remark and Blavatsky’s vision. With this in mind a reconstructed reading of Krishnamurti’s statement would result in the following: “Mrs.Besant [and Blavatsky] intended [subscribed to the view that] the land at Adyar [the Theosophical Society] to be meant [to be available] for the teaching [for the teacher]. The Theosophical Society has failed [did not to cooperate], the original purpose [the mission of the Theosophical Society to herald and aid the teacher] is destroyed [has not been fulfilled].” The point of this digression is to show that implicit in this remark is the self-perception of Krishnamurti as the teacher, who was expected and did come, but found the Theosophical Society not cooperative.

Annie Besant

Of all the leading theosophists Annie Besant was the most loyal to Krishnamurti during and after his repudiation of his mission in 1929. After hearing Krishnamurti speak at Krotona, California, in 1927 she told another Theosophist: “The Lord has spoken. I am now satisfied. This is the beginning of all that I have foreseen and worked for.” (13) Besant was so convinced that she declared herself to be his “devoted disciple,” (14) closed the Esoteric Section–the heart of the Theosophical Society and its link with the Masters–because only Krishnamurti should be allowed to teach, (15) and even considered giving up the presidency of the Theosophical Society to follow him. She adhered to the idea that a “fragment of the World-Teacher’s consciousness is in him [Krishnamurti], and his own is merged in it.” (16) Though she would reopen, allegedly on orders of her Master, the Esoteric Section and stayed on as president, she remained devoted to Krishnamurti, because he had, according to religious scholar and Theosophist Catherine Wessinger, “fulfilled her expectations concerning the World-Teacher in several basic respects.” (17) To bridge the points where Krishnamurti’s teachings and Theosophy differed Annie Besant applied her usual largesse of mind and logic: “Say, if you like, that we are two sides of one work. Dr.Besant is at the head of one side and Krishnaji of the other. One is the work of the Manu, the other of the Bodhisattva.” (18) Until the very end of her life Annie Besant tried to rise above all factions and schisms and as such was the embodiment of the first object of the Theosophical Society–Brotherhood.

Charles E. Luntz

Around 1929 a lively debate about Krishnamurti was held in the pages of The Theosophical Messenger, the official journal of the Theosophical Society in America, then edited by its national president, L.W.Rogers. An original contribution to this debate came from Charles E.Luntz with his “New Theory Regarding Krishnamurti and His Teaching,” named “The Great Testing.” According to this spiritual Darwinian theory, Krishnamurti’s remarks about Theosophy and the Theosophical Society were “a strange and unlooked for testing,” and “an onslaught designed to test its [the Theosophical Society’s] very soul,” with the purpose to make “the first great separation of the fit from the unfit (insofar as the Theosophical Society is concerned).” As the “weaklings drop out in their hundreds and even thousands, glad perhaps of the excuse this [Krishnamurti’s] extraordinary condemnation of all organizations gives them to relinquish the burden,” the “faithful few carry on,” with “wills of tempered steel” to perform the work of the “building of the new Root Race… under the direct guidance of the Manu”–a work which “calls for workers of courage, of self-sacrifice, of utter obedience and above all of Supreme Conviction of its transcendent importance.”

Did Krishnamurti know that he was the great tester? Not according to Luntz. It was his “well-reasoned belief that….the World Teacher, whose consciousness informs Krishnaji, has deliberately shut off from the latter’s physical brain the knowledge of the true reason for his attacks on the Theosophical Society.” (19)

Interestingly, there is the record of Krishnamurti’s reaction to this theory when he was asked in Adyar in 1933 “is the ruthless manner of the presentation of your views merely a test of our devotion to the Masters and our loyalty to the Theosophical Society…?” Part of Krishnamurti’s answer was: “I have told you what I really think. If you wish to use that as a test to fortify yourselves, to entrench yourselves in your old beliefs, I cannot help it.” (20) But this answer was anticipated by Luntz in his 1930 article: “If by any chance this hypothesis comes to the attention of Krishnaji he will undoubtedly deny it… Those who accept it need not be concerned, recognizing that if it be true it must be denied by him in all sincerity or the test would fail.”

This theory puts Krishnamurti in the strange position that, if he effectively wanted to refute the theory, he only had to contradict the expected behavior by saying that Luntz was right! Any attempt by Krishnamurti to refute this theory by saying it was not true would be futile. The adherents of the theory would see in that effort a confirmation of their idea.

Radha Burnier

After Annie Besant died in 1933 relations between Krishnamurti and the Theosophical Society were severed although he would still have private contacts with individual members. Krishnamurti did not visit the Theosophical compound at Adyar for forty-six years. When his close friend Radha Burnier, who worked for the Krishnamurti Foundation while being head of the Esoteric School of the Theosophical Society at the same time, became president of the Theosophical Society in 1980, an event he wished for and apparently actively promoted, (21) Krishnamurti agreed to visit the grounds of the Theosophical headquarters again. For the rest of his life, whenever he was in Madras, he would go there for a walk along the beach, the very same place where he was discovered by Leadbeater.

Under the leadership of its present president, Radha Burnier, the Theosophical Society seems to come back from an ambivalent position towards Krishnamurti and a consensus seems to be emerging, at least at the international headquarters of the Theosophical Society, to accept Krishnamurti as the prophesied teacher. Two special issues of The Theosophist, one an obituary to Krishnamurti and the other dedicated to Krishnamurti’s centennial, are both endorsements of Krishnamurti’s teachings and both suggest that he should be regarded as the World-Teacher. (22) In the first one Burnier, who is the editor of The Theosophist, wrote that the “connection between J.Krishnamurti… and the Theosophical Society was broken, not because he left–as many members believe–but because

people were not ready to listen to a profound message given in terms they were not accustomed to hearing. It is not the first time that this has happened. The Jews would not listen to Jesus when he came to teach. The majority of Hindus did not respond for long to what the Buddha had to say.” (23) In short, Krishnamurti did his job as messiah and the Theosophists lacked the insight to recognize him as such.

Jean Overton Fuller and Krishnamurti again

In an obituary for Krishnamurti published in Theosophical History, Jean Overton Fuller, a scholarly Theosophical author, passed on a view which she heard from some French Theosophists and later from an English professor. She stated that Besant and Leadbeater were not necessarily wrong “when they thought they recognized in him the World Teacher.” They were even “right, in the first moment in which they recognized him as who he was,” but were “wrong in practically everything they did in consequence.” In the beginning Krishnamurti “seemed to go along with their way of thinking, but as he matured, he began to show skepticism concerning the build-up of which he was the centerpiece.” (24) In other words, Krishnamurti was from the beginning the expected teacher, but was in no need of special training. Nor did he need any special organization to proclaim his coming. When he himself realized he was the teacher he gradually broke away from all the erroneous concepts and structures built around him.

Gregory Tillett conceived a similar possibility, though he seems not quite sure: “Was Krishnamurti a genius from birth who could have achieved international status as a philosopher regardless of who had taken him out of his environment of poverty, or did he become what he is as a result of Leadbeater’s training?” (25)

In an indirect way, Krishnamurti himself also suggested the same idea. In the same conversations referred to above between Mary Lutyens, Mary Zimbalist, and himself, he delved, in a very subtle way, into the question of the “boy” Krishnamurti, his vacant mind, and the power that protected him. “The boy was affectionate, vacant, not intellectual, enjoyed athletic games. What is important in this is the vacant mind. How could that vacant mind come to this [the teaching]? Was vacancy necessary for this to manifest?… How was it that the vacant mind was not filled with Theosophy etc.?” According to Krishnamurti this “vacancy was guarded,” “the vacancy has never gone away,” “the boy was found, conditioning took no hold–neither the Theosophy, nor the adulation, nor the World Teacher, the property, the enormous sums of money–none of it affected him.” (26) He said that in spite of his upbringing in Theosophy, his mind was kept vacant and protected by a higher power to facilitate the transmission of a teaching. He seemed to imply that that would have happened regardless of “Theosophy etc.”

VIEW TWO: THE PROJECT WAS GENUINE, BUT FAILED

Charles Webster Leadbeater

Many Theosophists believe that either because of Leadbeater’s clairvoyance or a transcendent power acting upon him, he perceived the potential spiritual greatness in Krishnamurti when they met on the beach next to the international headquarters of the Theosophical Society in May 1909. At that time Krishnamurti was an underfed, scrawny and dirty teenager. As for his mental capacity, Krishnamurti was even considered dim-witted by Theosophist Ernest Wood, who tried to help him with his homework. Leadbeater also was the first one to communicate the idea that Krishnamurti was to be trained as the vehicle for the Lord Maitreya. (27) As the allegedly clairvoyant and prescient originator of the project of the coming of a great teacher, Leadbeater’s views on the project’s fulfillment carry a certain weight. There is a problem though in evaluating his articles and public statements, for Leadbeater would always support Annie Besant’s position in public even when he thought that she was wrong. (28) As Besant was convinced that Krishnamurti was the World-Teacher, Leadbeater would not let her down. In his most important article on the subject, “`Art Thou He That Should Come?,'” he stated, referring to Krishnamurti: “This is He who should come, and there is no need to look elsewhere; as I have said, I know that the World-Teacher often speaks through Krishnaji,” and then comes the twist, “but I also know that there are occasions when He does not.” (29)

What Leadbeater really thought was only expressed in private, for example in 1927 at Adyar to Adrian Vreede, a colleague-bishop in the Liberal Catholic Church, to whom he confided that “The Coming had gone wrong.” (30) Because Leadbeater kept his views to himself it is hard to find out why he thought the coming had gone wrong. He was visibly perturbed by the 1925 occult revelations originating from the Theosophical estate in Huizen, Holland, where Theosophist George Arundale and others were transmitting messages from the Masters. (31) Allegedly on the Masters’ orders Arundale appointed ten apostles, announced the passing of initiations, consecrated an Abbess, and gave many instructions. These messages were never accepted by Leadbeater as genuine and Krishnamurti himself reacted skeptically, even sarcastically. Krishnamurti said that “everything was spoiled.” (32) Besant, though, did accept them and divulged much of their content in her public addresses, which put Krishnamurti in a extremely difficult situation. Leadbeater told Adrian Vreede that “this explosion [of questionable revelations] has done more to hinder the coming of the Lord than anything else.”(33) To summarize, it is clear that Leadbeater believed that the project was genuine, that Krishnamurti was occasionally overshadowed by Maitreya, but that something had gone wrong.

Leadbeater blamed not only Krishnamurti himself for the failure of the project, but also deluded influential Theosophists.

Geoffrey Hodson

A clairvoyant description of an address by Krishnamurti at the Star-camp at Ommen in 1927 can be found in Geoffrey Hodson’s article “Camp-Fire Gleams.” (34) His visions of Krishnamurti being overshadowed by the Christ or Lord Maitreya might have convinced many people that the coming was a success. But was Hodson himself convinced? Initially he was, but not so later on, if one believes John Robertson, who wrote an unpublished biography on Hodson’s life. Robertson was told by Hodson that the coming had not been “fulfilled strictly in the terms of the original pronouncement;” that “on certain rare occasions this overshadowing was experimentally begun,” but these manifestations were “both gentle and brief.” As for the reasons for terminating the experiment, Hodson thought that “perhaps the strain proved too great for Krishnamurti.” Hodson told Robertson that Krishnamurti’s doctor had said that (quoting Hodson) the “strain upon Krishnamurti’s nervous system and psychology was very great, even after only a few minutes use of his vehicles by a higher Being.” Another factor were circumstances and actions which had “deeply hurt his susceptibilities” (probably referring to the Huizen-manifestations). Or the death in 1925 of his beloved brother Nityananda, whose life Krishnamurti thought to be crucial to his destiny, was a factor “in his decision to withdraw from the role that might have been his.” According to Robertson, Hodson also said that “this does not in any way deny the fact that the original plan of a wholly `experimental’ attempt to use Krishnamurti as a vehicle was formed and communicated by a Master to C.W.Leadbeater. In fact, Mr.Hodson stated that he has reason to be firmly convinced that this was indeed the case.” (35)

Unfortunately, as has been pointed out by German author Peter Michel, many of Hodson’s writings containing his views on Krishnamurti have not been published. (36) These include “The Unforgettable Years,” a manuscript containing his remembrances and visions from approximately the period 1923-1930, the entries of his “occult diary” for the same years which were not included in the publication edited by his wife, (37) and his biography “Aquarian Occultist.” He did publish a little booklet in 1935, Krishnamurti and the Search for Light, in which he defended Theosophy and the Theosophical Society against Krishnamurti’s iconoclasm, because he felt that “the principles of justice, fair play and common courtesy have been so flagrantly outraged for some seven years that at last I am moved to a reply.” As a member of the Theosophical Society he had “not always been able to achieve the philosophic calm of the leaders,” so he had to express his view on Krishnamurti’s teachings. According to Hodson the teachings of Krishnamurti were “an extraordinary blend of rare flashes of transcendental wisdom, penetrating intelligence, incomprehensibility, prejudice, intolerance and vituperation.” (38) Later in life Hodson took a milder view. He stated that “the splendid

teachings, verbal and written,.. demonstrate that he is indeed, in his own right, an advanced Soul with an aspiring message to deliver to mankind.” (39) Based on his clairvoyance Hodson accepted the project as genuine, saw the Christ working through Krishnamurti, but later he had reasons to conclude that Krishnamurti had rejected his role. Despite this and the fact that Krishnamurti became prejudiced against Theosophy, Hodson thought he had something important to say.

Cyril Scott

Between 1920 and 1932 the English composer and Theosophist, Cyril Scott, anonymously wrote three still popular occult books, which tell the story of a poet, Charles Broadbent, and his spiritual teacher, Justin Moreward Haig (who himself was a initiated disciple of a Master of Wisdom, named “Sir Thomas”). (40) Considered by many as fiction, the author himself stated about the last book of the series, that the “various situations in the book were correctly portrayed, but the characters for obvious reasons had perforce to be camouflaged.” (41) In this third book, The Initiate in the Dark Cycle, two chapters were entirely dedicated to Krishnamurti, (42) and “its most valuable portions were contributed by the Initiate’s Master.” (43) Early in the recorded conversation in the second of the two chapters, Haig stated that “instead of giving forth the new Teaching so badly needed, he [Krishnamurti] escaped from the responsibilities of his office as prophet and teacher by reverting to a past incarnation, and an ancient philosophy.” Haig then stated that Krishnamurti is teaching the Advaita (monist) version of Vedanta philosophy. “Sir Thomas” added that this is a “philosophy for chelas, and one of the most easily misunderstood paths to Liberation.” He also warned those who climb Krishnamurti’s “incomplete stairway to God” of two dangers. “Danger Number One: Krishnamurti’s casting aside of time-honoured definitions and classifications leaves aspirant without true scale of values. Danger Number Two: climbing his particular staircase necessitates constant meditation, which in its turn necessitates constant protection from Guru–and Guru not allowed by Krishnamurti.” As his final evaluation when asked if Krishnamurti’s “mission must be regarded as a total failure,” he stated “True, true. A success while still overshadowed by the World-Teacher,… a failure afterwards.” (44) In short, Krishnamurti rejected his role, dug up an old teaching and turned it into something dangerous.

During a talk in 1936 Krishnamurti was asked his reaction to the allegation in The Initiate in the Dark Cycle that what he is teaching is “Advaitism, which is a philosophy only for yogis and chelas, and dangerous for the average individual.” Krishnamurti’s answer was as follows. “Surely, if I considered that what I am saying is dangerous for the average person, I wouldn’t talk. So, it is for you to consider if what I say is dangerous. People who write books of this kind are consciously or unconsciously exploiting others. They have axes to grind, and having committed themselves to a certain system, they bring in the authority of a Master, of tradition, of superstition, of churches, which

generally controls the activities of an individual. What is there in what I am saying that is so difficult or dangerous for the average man?” (45) The question about the difficulty of Krishnamurti’s teaching was answered in “Sir Thomas”‘ last words about Krishnamurti in Scott’s book: “Because he has reached a certain state of consciousness and evolution, in his modesty he fails to see that others have not reached it likewise. Therefore he prescribes for others what is only suitable for himself.” (46)

David Anrias

One of the characters in Scott’s initiate-books is an astrologer named David Anrias. His real name was Brian Ross, an English Theosophist who had worked for Annie Besant in India. (47) He claimed to have been in contact with the Masters, some of whose messages and portraits he published in Through the Eyes of the Masters. In a later book Anrias let it be known that this book “was partly inspired with the object of counteracting the doubt cast by Krishnamurti upon the power of the Masters to further the evolution of mankind.” (48) The most important message came from Lord Maitreya himself and dealt almost exclusively with Krishnamurti. Maitreya said that he was “limited by Karma in the choice of [his] Medium,” that he had to use “a physical body selected by the Lords of Karma,” which was “untrained in many respects for the difficult task of a Spiritual Teacher.” Because Krishnamurti had taken initiations along the line of the Deva-evolutions, “it became all but impossible for him to be used any longer as my medium.” His main criticism was that “although Krishnamurti was right to emphasize the necessity for independent thought, he was wrong in assuming that everyone else, regardless of past Karma and present limitations, could instantly reach that point which he himself had only reached through lives of effort, and by the aid of those Cosmic Forces apportioned to him solely for his office as Herald of the New Age.”(49) Briefly stated: Krishnamurti was a deficient vehicle, took the wrong initiations, and promulgated a big error.

Alice Bailey

Alice Bailey claimed to have been contacted by the Tibetan Master Djual Kul, who transmitted to her a voluminous body of teachings. In Djual Kul’s teachings the Christ played a prominent role and was expected to return to earth. This return “will be expressed… by an upsurging of the Christ consciousness in the hearts of men everywhere” and many “will be `overshadowed’ by Him.” In this way “He will duplicate Himself repeatedly.” His work with Krishnamurti was one of the first experiments as a means of preparation, but it “was only partially successful. The power used by Him was distorted and misapplied by the devotee type of which the Theosophical Society is largely composed, and the experiment was brought to an end.” (50) Bailey’s position seems to be that the project was genuine but experimental, and was terminated because Theosophists were not of the right type.

Guy Ballard

According to Guy Ballard, an American mining engineer with an interest in the occult, the Adept Saint Germain approached him with the request to become a messenger for the Adepts. This happened in the summer of 1930 on the slopes of Mount Shasta, California, almost exactly a year after Krishnamurti had dissolved the Order of the Star. Ballard agreed, wrote Unveiled Mysteries under the name Godfré Ray King and founded with his wife Edna the “I AM” Movement. (51) Three ex-members of the “I AM” Movement I met, who remembered the 1920s and 1930s and had some knowledge about Theosophy and Krishnamurti, agreed that the reason for the founding of the “I AM” Movement was the failing of Krishnamurti–the Masters of Wisdom had to open a new channel to give a new teaching, because Krishnamurti would not do so. There is no direct reference to Krishnamurti in the literature of the “I AM” Movement to support that view, and its present day leaders, when asked about the possible connection of Krishnamurti’s alleged failure and the founding of the “I AM” Movement, could only state that somehow Theosophy had failed and that was the reason why the Masters turned to Ballard. Nevertheless some passages found in the “I AM” literature have a direct bearing on our subject. They can be found in “Kuthumi’s Discourse,” a message by the Adept Kuthumi given through Ballard on December 19, 1937, in Los Angeles. Though Krishnamurti was not mentioned by name and the passage refers to possibly a multitude of individuals, the plausibility that it refers also to Krishnamurti has to be considered seriously.

  • In Our Endeavor to assist and bring forth through Theosophy the Glory and right Understanding of Life, up to the time when We could have brought forth this Truth, still again humanity would not give sufficient obedience. Why will not mankind, precious mankind, give obedience to the Law of Life–love each other, so that it makes it possible for the great Truth to come forth untouched, unadulterated by human opinions!… Beloved Ones, for more than six hundred years the Great Ascended Masters have tried to open the way for this greater Understanding to come to mankind; but no sooner did this Mighty Truth begin to expand Its Light, than individuals with human opinions seized upon It and tried to make It obey them, instead of obeying It… Do you realize, Beloved Ones, what it means to Us, to Morya and Myself–We two who were so earnest and sincere? Yet, Our beloved Saint Germain has accomplished more in three years than We did in the many years of Our humble Efforts. (52)

The last sentence sounds boastful, but is not without substance if one considers the observation about the “I AM” Movement by religious scholar and Theosophist Robert Ellwood that “at its apex in the late thirties, it must have represented the greatest popular diffusion Theosophical concepts ever attained.” (53)

Did Krishnamurti try to subsume the revelations, which initially came through him, under his own opinions, and because of that could not give the full truth, which was then revealed through

another vehicle? Krishnamurti’s anticipation to a part of this criticism can be found in the very last sentences of his famous speech dissolving the Order of the Star. “For two years I have been thinking about this, slowly, carefully, patiently, and I have now decided to disband the Order, as I happen to be its Head. You can form other organizations and expect someone else. With that I am not concerned, nor with creating new cages, [and] new decorations for those cages.” (54)

Elizabeth Clare Prophet

As the leader of a new religious movement Elizabeth Clare Prophet claims to be the Messenger for the Great White Brotherhood and as such “takes dictations” from different Masters of Wisdom. The movement, known formerly as the Summit Lighthouse and more recently as Church Universal and Triumphant, has its roots in Theosophy and the “I AM” Movement. (55) With the latter the Summit Lighthouse has so much in common that a Dutch study of the organization stated that one could perhaps see the Summit Lighthouse as the “I AM” Movement “risen from its ashes.” (56) The dictations have been published on a weekly basis for the last thirty-five years. In 1975 Kuthumi delivered a message with a couple of paragraphs dedicated to Krishnamurti. He stated forthrightly (“let the chips fall where they may”) that Krishnamurti was “the instrument of a philosophy that is not and does not in any way represent the true teachings of the Great White Brotherhood” and that Krishnamurti presented “calculated and cunning detours for souls searching for truth.” Regarding the coming and its failure Kuthumi stated that though Krishnamurti was “selected to take the training for the calling of representing the World Teachers and the coming Buddha, Lord Maitreya,” he “failed the test of the intellect and of the subtleties of spiritual pride,” with the result that he is now “denounced by the Brotherhood,” while he himself “denounces the true teachers and the path of initiation.” (57)

Earlier in the same year El Morya allegedly privately dictated a series of letters to Prophet. In the last letter of the series he gives a chronological overview of the different projects the Masters had been involved with, starting with Blavatsky and Mary Baker Eddy. About these two spiritual pioneers he said that though they were “at times beset with their own preconceptions and the burden of the mass consciousness, these witnesses codified the truth and the law of East and West as the culmination of thousands of years of their souls’ distillations of the Spirit.” In the next paragraph he then makes what one can only take as a veiled reference to Krishnamurti. “Such messengers are not trained in a day or a year or a lifetime. Embodiment after embodiment, they sit at the feet of the masters and receive the emanations of their mantle in the power of their word and example. A number of others who were selected to perform a similar service for hierarchy failed in their initiations through the pride of their intellect and their unwillingness to submit identity totally unto the flame. They have become thereby totally self-deluded and they continue to draw innocent souls into the chaos of their delusion.” (58) For two reasons this paragraph can be construed as referring to Krishnamurti. The

strongest one is the key phrase “at the feet of the masters,” which is also the title of Krishnamurti’s first publication, and regarded a Theosophical classic. The second reason is the place the paragraph takes in the chronological overview. It is placed between the paragraph about Blavatsky and Eddy, and a paragraph about Guy and Edna Ballard, who are presented as “representatives tried and true of Saint Germain.” (59) This suggests to look for these allegedly failed messengers in the period between Blavatsky’s death in 1891 and the meeting between Guy Ballard and Saint Germain in 1930. This period covers exactly the time beginning with the leadership of the Theosophical Society by Besant and ending with the abrogation–or culmination, depending on one’s view–of her world teacher project in the dissolution of the Order of the Star in 1929 by Krishnamurti himself. If these two reasons hold, and the paragraph is really a reference to Krishnamurti, then it is the most severe evaluation of him on record.

In short, according to Prophet’s Masters, Krishnamurti was selected and trained by the Masters for an important role, subsequently tripped over his pride and deceived vulnerable souls with a subtle but erroneous philosophy.

[See also text of a little lecture by Elizabeth Prophet on Krishnamurti not used in the above paragraphs]

Peter Michel

Among the many studies about the life and teachings of Krishnamurti, perhaps one stands out because of its exploration of a very wide variety of subjects and issues connected with Krishnamurti. It also stands out because it is very sympathetic to Theosophical concepts and experiences, while at heart being in accord with Krishnamurti. This study by the German author Peter Michel is titled Krishnamurti–Love and Freedom.

Regarding the idea of the coming of a great spiritual teacher Michel states that it is likely that the origin of the idea of the World-Teacher in Besant’s and Leadbeater’s worldview “can be found in their inner experiences” of communication with the Masters. For him it even “seems to make no sense to consider an outer source to account for the idea of the World Teacher.” As for his views on the success of the coming, he observes the paradox, that “Krishnamurti regarded himself more as a World Teacher later–in his own right–than the Theosophists, whose messianic ideal he had rejected inwardly and outwardly for several years, ever did.” He quotes Krishnamurti, seemingly in agreement, from an interesting interview Krishnamurti gave to an American journalist. “The teachers of all ages have repeated the same essentials but we never seem to understand them, perhaps because of their very simplicity. And so, when it becomes necessary for humanity to receive in a new form the ancient wisdom someone whose duty it is to repeat these truths is incarnated.” (60) Answering his own question “if K was `the teacher’ like Christ or Buddha,” Michel agrees “with Scott and Anrias that he was not,” to which he added the observation that “K himself would reply: Is this of any importance?” According to Michel,

Krishnamurti “might have been the `teacher,'” if “he would have been able to combine his position (the non-esoteric K) with the best of the esoteric tradition, as it maybe was planned.” (61) Peter Michel’s position seems to be very close to the one described above for Hodson, i.e., Krishnamurti was not the expected teacher, but his teachings are important. The difference between Hodson and Michel is that Hodson’s sympathy is more with Theosophy and Michel’s sympathy is more with Krishnamurti.

VIEW THREE: THE PROJECT WAS NOT GENUINE AND FAILED

Rudolf Steiner

The founding of the Anthroposophical Society in 1912 by Rudolf Steiner was a direct consequence of the views he held about the second coming of the Christ. When the Order of the Star was founded, the Council of the German Section of the Theosophical Society, of which Steiner was then general secretary, declared that no one could be simultaneously a member of the Star and the German TS. Besant reacted by revoking their charter, which officially took effect on March 7, 1913. Meanwhile, Steiner had founded the Anthroposophical Society on December 28, 1912, and the majority of German Theosophists followed him. (62)

His differences with Besant and Leadbeater regarding the nature of the Christ were fundamental. In a series of lectures given in 1911, when he was still with the Theosophical Society, he stated that the first coming of the Christ, “the Christ-Event,” was a unique unrepeatable cosmic event. “An incarnation of the Christ-Being in a human body of flesh could take place only once in the course of the Earth-evolution.” The essential event of the coming happened during the crucifixion, when the earth was redeemed by the influx of the spirit of Christ. The second coming meant for Steiner “the renewal of the [first] Christ-Event” and would happen “towards the end of the twentieth century,” this time not in a physical way, but “in the world of the etheric.” This “second Christ-Event” would consist of Christ becoming “Lord of Karma for human evolution” and would have the effect that more and more people would be able to perceive “the significance and the Being of Christ.” (63)

Steiner also differed with Besant and Leadbeater on the question of who Christ was. Besant and Leadbeater identified him with the Bodhisattva Maitreya. Steiner said they were two different, but related, beings; Christ was not a highly evolved human soul as the Theosophist saw him, but an infinitely higher cosmic being. The Bodhisattva Maitreya, “who succeeded Gautama Buddha,” was

a human soul, who, as Jeshu ben Pandira in a former incarnation, prepared the way for Christ. This Maitreya has “one of his re-embodiments …fixed for the twentieth century,” about which it was “impossible to speak here more exactly.” (64)

It will not be a surprise that Steiner thought that the coming as envisioned by Besant and Leadbeater “simply means that the Christ-Being [was] not understood” and that their idea was an “absurdity.” (65) But the absurdity was not of their own making. According to Steiner the original Masters who had directed Blavatsky–“those supreme powers, which presided at the inauguration of the Theosophical Society”–had been surreptitiously replaced by “powers, wishing to follow their own special interests.” These powers had taken on “the appearance of those who had originally inspired the impulse.” Steiner identified these impostors as being of Indian origin and as having the motive of revenging themselves on the imperialistic and materialistic West by merging their “own nationalistic egoistic occultism,” into an “occult movement from the West,” i.e. the Theosophical Society. This was made possible “through the very way in which England and India are karmically connected with one another in world affairs.” The result was that the “spiritual forces which sought to bestow upon mankind a new impulse without distinction of race, creed, or any other merely human attributes were dammed back.” (66) In other words, according to Steiner, impostor Masters had hijacked the Theosophical Society, and used Besant, Leadbeater and Krishnamurti as unwitting instruments in a occult power game directed against humanity in general and the West in particular. (67)

Albert E.S. Smythe

After the dust had settled around Krishnamurti’s radical pronouncements and actions in 1929, Albert E.S.Smythe, then General Secretary of the Canadian section of the Theosophical Society, expressed what certain Theosophists had thought all along about Besant, Leadbeater, and the project of the coming teacher: a “large part of the Theosophical movement never shared these views, the Canadian Section of the Society having repudiated them from the first.” He called the project an “extraordinary delusion” and “absolutely contrary” to the literature of the Theosophical Society of Blavatsky’s days. In Smythe’s eyes Leadbeater was the main culprit. He had “seized” the young Krishnamurti, had “evangelized Mrs Annie Besant” and persuaded her with “the most fanatical and ridiculous arguments” that the boy was to be a World Teacher. Fortunately, Krishnamurti saw through it and freed himself from the “influence of his crazy patron, shook off the delusions with which he had been surrounded and now announces that he has cut loose from the whole of these fictitious traditions.” (68) Innocent and abused, Krishnamurti woke up in time to claim his independence.

E.L.Gardner

In 1963 an eminent English Theosophist, E.L.Gardner, wrote a booklet about Leadbeater’s clairvoyance, which caused a furor in Theosophical circles. (69) Gardner’s contention was that, although Leadbeater discovered the boy Krishnamurti by an act of genuine clairvoyance, Leadbeater later fell victim to “unconscious Kriyashakti.” Gardner defined the term Kriyashakti as the power of creative thought. The concept of “unconscious Kriyashakti” is best explained by Leadbeater’s biographer Gregory Tillett: “Leadbeater unconsciously created an entire artificial system, based upon his own strongly held views, and, again unconsciously, used his own occult power to vitalize this system into a state where it had the appearance of reality, and appeared as an objective reality to him when he viewed it clairvoyantly.” (70) Or, as Gardner stated succinctly “the Lord Maitreya and the Masters with whom Leadbeater was on such familiar terms were his own thought-creations.” (71) In this way Leadbeater created, and also sincerely believed in, the project of the second coming, messages from the Masters, and their guidance in reforming the Liberal Catholic Church and other projects.

VIEW FOUR: PROJECT WAS NOT GENUINE, BUT SUCCEEDED.

Rom Landau and an “Impeccable Source”

The matrix would not be complete without someone claiming that the project was simultaneously not genuine, and miraculously successful. Rom Landau, who interviewed many metaphysical teachers in the 1930s, presents such a version in his book God Is My Adventure. He “heard it for the first time from Ouspensky” and “since its source is impeccable,” he quoted it. It should be stressed that it is not necessarily Ouspensky’s own version, although that could be the case. To quote Landau again: “According to this version, Leadbeater’s original `vision’ was pure invention. Together with Mrs.Besant he is supposed to have believed that a young human being brought up as a `messiah’–educated in an appropriate manner and supported by a worldwide wave of love and the implicit faith of great masses of people–ought to develop certain Christlike qualities; and it appears that Leadbeater and Annie Besant believed to the very end that Krishnamurti was thus developing naturally into the personality of the `World Teacher.'” (72) Great ends justify great lies?

NON-THEOSOPHICAL OBSERVATIONS

Arthur H. Nethercot

As the biographer of Annie Besant’s multi-faceted life, Arthur Nethercot had to take into account Krishnamurti’s life and the way it was related to Besant. One point specifically puzzled Nethercot about Krishnamurti and that was his loss of memory of everything that had happened before 1929. Apparently this loss did not happen in that year itself for Nethercot had interviewed people who stated that even in 1932 Krishnamurti was able to remember “these earlier events perfectly.” As not to impugn Krishnamurti’s integrity Nethercot proposed the following explanation:

  • Here then is an extraordinary case of a man who, after a long and bizarre struggle with life, has finally got himself and his mind under almost complete control–has perhaps hypnotized himself so that he can relegate to oblivion most of the things he does not want to remember, because they recall the unhappy days when he was becoming an individual and was escaping from the domination of others whom he had cause to love and admire…I should hate to think of him as a charlatan; I prefer to think of him as a sort of schizophrenic, or at least a man of a now permanently divided dual personality. (73)

Nethercot seems to suggest that Krishnamurti was mentally ill because he suppressed his past.

Krishnamurti’s thoughts about his memory are contained in a letter from Mary Lutyens to Nethercot, when the latter had requested her to raise the question of Krishnamurti’s memory again. She wrote that “there is no question of amnesia; he is just not interested in the past and cannot bring his mind to it and cannot see its importance….He wouldn’t be able to tell you what happened a fortnight ago….He is very fully alive in the present and excited about what goes on inside himself from day to day. What that is it is impossible to say, for he lives in a world and state of consciousness so different from the normal that one can scarcely glimpse it…” (74)

Radha Rajagopal Sloss

Radha Rajagopal Sloss dropped a little bomb in the Krishnamurti circles in 1991 by alleging that her mother, Rosalind Rajagopal, the wife of Krishnamurti’s former friend, manager and publisher, Desikacharya Rajagopal, had a secret love affair with Krishnamurti from 1932 until approximately 1957. This revelation, now admitted to be true by the Krishnamurti Foundation of America, might have done irreparable damage to Krishnamurti’s image as a celibate, but as physical love is not contradictory to his teachings, the disclosure will probably soon be considered irrelevant.

More important and possibly damaging is Sloss’ allegation about Krishnamurti’s involvement in the termination of Rosalind’s third pregnancy by Krishnamurti and the observations of Sloss and others about his behavior in the Krishnamurti-Rajagopal feud over funds, real estate, and archives. According to Sloss the real cause of the fight was Krishnamurti’s fear about “what would happen to his public image if letters and statements in his own handwriting should ever come to light. He wished to acquire control over these archives by whatever means necessary.” (75) This alleged obsession drove Krishnamurti to maligning Rajagopal, and to instigating a lawsuit accusing Rajagopal of mismanaging funds. (76) Some, who were close to both men, and had knowledge of the case, tried, in vain, to mend fences. Sloss reproduced their letters with their observations: “One day, history will reveal everything; but the division in Krishnamurti himself will cast a very dark shadow on all he has said or written. Because the first thing the readers will say, is: `If he cannot live it, who can?'” This last statement was echoed in another letter: “It has been obvious to me Krishnaji is not living his own teaching, that he has been making war.” An explanation for this was offered by Sloss, which is similar to Nethercot’s view of Krishnamurti: “Krishna was more than one person.” She does not elaborate the statement, but rather illustrates it. She wrote that within a short time-span Rosalind, who also tried to mediate between Krishnamurti and Rajagopal, experienced Krishnamurti first as “absolutely impervious to her words, withdrawn and haughty” and ten days later as “loving and appeared willing to talk” and wanting to “try to straighten things out.” She found talking to “two Krishnas,” a “strange and unsettling experience.” (77)

Krishnamurti’s reaction to criticism of a perceived dichotomy between his words and his deeds can be found in conversations he had with trustees of the Krishnamurti Foundation of America in 1972. According to a booklet published by the same foundation, he made it clear in these conversations, that “the desire for consistency between the teacher and the teachings simply mirrors the conditioning of the questioner.” Questioning the relationship between a teacher and his teachings from the point of view of a hypothetical “man in the street,” Krishnamurti said: “I’m not interested in what the Buddha was when he was a young man, whether he had sex, no sex, drugs or no drugs. I’m not interested. What I am interested in is what he is saying?” “Just… share into his teaching so that I can lead a different kind of life… I am only interested in the teaching. Nothing else–who you are, who you’re not. Whether you’re real or honest. It is my life that I am concerned with, not with your life…” Coming back to addressing the person to whom he was talking directly, he said: “How do you know he is honest or dishonest?” “How do you know whether what he is saying is out of his own life or he is inventing? Inventing in the big sense? Or he’s leading a double life?” “I would say `Please, leave the personality alone.'” (78)

The question might arise whether Krishnamurti was sincere in this conversation or was applying preventive damage-control. As we have seen, Krishnamurti’s reaction to such a question would probably be challenging the questioner about his own conditioning, and dismissing the issue

as irrelevant. To this answer the same skepticism about Krishnamurti’s sincerity might be rejoined. This locks the discussion in a solid stalemate, which is anyway the logical conclusion of a reciprocated ad hominem argument.

THE AGNOSTIC META-POSITION

John Algeo

The views of the current president of the Theosophical Society in America, John Algeo, are of importance because he gives a Theosophical framework for understanding the observations of Nethercot and Sloss; because he is an exception from the earlier referred to emerging consensus in the Theosophical Society to accept Krishnamurti as the prophesied teacher, and because he has an alternative view of Krishnamurti.

John Algeo also observes that Krishnamurti “appears to have been not one, but several persons”: a) “the young Krishnamurti, nurtured and conditioned by his Theosophical mentors”; b) “the rebellious and publicly austere Krishnamurti, overthrowing his Theosophical traces and…teaching ends without means”; c) “the esoteric Krishnamurti,” with powers of healing and clairvoyancy; d) “the charismatic Krishnamurti,” who seemed to have “realized his unity with the source of all life” and e) the “manipulative, dishonest, self-centered Krishnamurti,” revealed by Sloss. To answer the question “who is the real Krishnamurti?” Algeo applies Theosophical psychology: “Each of us is a transcendent individuality that expresses itself in a series of reincarnated personalities….The various Krishnamurtis are mixtures in varying proportions of aspects of the flawed personality and the inspiring individuality.” (79)

If the Theosophical concept of personality can be equated with Krishnamurti’s concept of the ego, then Krishnamurti would reject this view out of hand. When Krishnamurti discussed with Radha Sloss the conflict between himself and Rajagopal and was challenged by Sloss’ remark–which she characterized as “going too far”–that for her the whole affair seemed to be “a conflict of ego and pride and surely you of all people should be able to deal with that,” Krishnamurti’s voice, according to Sloss, “changed completely from a formal indifference to heated anger,” and became “almost shrill,” and he said “I have no ego! Who do you think you are, to talk to me like this?” (80) Is Krishnamurti’s way of delivering this statement contradicting its content? The question it raises, and this one has profound and interesting implications, is whether to view Krishnamurti’s reaction as rooted in righteous indignation of an enlightened, inspiring individuality or as an outburst of anger of an egoic, flawed personality. In the first case Krishnamurti’s self-perception as an enlightened being stands untouched, in the second it would fall apart.

The other point of interest in Algeo’s review is his warning that Krishnamurti’s “influence on the organizational and intellectual history” of the Theosophical Society “could lead to a different sort of dogma and sectarianism….There is a tendency to idealize Krishnamurti, to find in him a de facto World Teacher, and to repress his shadow side.” (81) Does this last statement imply that Algeo thinks Krishnamurti is not the World Teacher? When asked the question about the genuineness and success of the project with Krishnamurti, he answered that he “could not know that and would not speculate about it.” (82) This answer suggests a legitimate epistemological view of the matrix, which could be termed an agnostic one: one does not know the truth about Krishnamurti’s metaphysical status and there is a risk involved in making a leap of faith into believing one position or another.

THE KANTIAN META-POSITION

Krishnamurti again.

A variation to the last-mentioned position would be the Kantian statement that one could not, in principle, know the truth about the metaphysical side of Krishnamurti, because that is the realm, as Krishnamurti himself stated, “where our brains, our instruments of investigation, have no meaning.” Here we are back to where we started with Krishnamurti’s observation about himself that “water can never find out what water is.” But we proceeded with presenting a number of metaphysical views, partly encouraged by his challenge that “if you are open to enquire, put your brain in condition, someone could find out.” (83)

CONCLUSION

The matrix I proposed in this paper to classify the great amount of different Theosophical viewpoints about the person Krishnamurti seems to be helpful, because the two issues of genuineness and success regarding the project of the coming of a great spiritual teacher, are, implicitly or explicitly, almost always dealt with by Theosophical writers when they discuss Krishnamurti. For that reason the matrix seems to provide a clear structure to the field of enquiry.

There are certain interesting features to this structure which are worth mentioning.

1. Different strategies are devised to reconcile Krishnamurti’s teachings with Theosophy by those who believe the project was genuine and successful. Because of Krishnamurti’s rejection of Theosophy this task will be hard to execute. To begin with Krishnamurti himself; though dismissing Theosophy, he seems to keep the door open by acknowledging the existence of the Masters and the idea of the Boddhisattva. Besant solves the dilemma by regarding the two teachings as two sides of the same coin, each with its own specific function for humanity. Luntz qualifies Krishnamurti’s statements as deliberate falsehoods to test Theosophists, without impugning Krishnamurti’s integrity. Burnier depicts Krishnamurti as a profound, but misunderstood Theosophical teacher, who got expelled by the Theosophical Society. And finally Overton Fuller blames Besant’s and Leadbeater’s brand of Theosophy for Krishnamurti’s estrangement.

2. There is a significant majority of persons believing the project was genuine. Of the 20 persons whose views have been presented, 13 viewed the project as genuine as against 4 who saw it as not genuine. It could of course be argued that these figures are a result of an arbitrary selection and that the numbers would be different if, for example, Edouard Schuré, Eugène Lévy, Katherine Tingley, Bhagavan Das and others would be included on the side of those holding to position 3. But then one could also swell the ranks of those believing the project to be genuine with George Arundale, James Wedgwood, E.A.Wodehouse, Emily Lutyens etc.

3. All views stating that the project was not genuine (Steiner, Smythe, Gardner and Landau) incorporate different occult and non-occult conceptions of deception with a central role for Leadbeater. This is no surprise, because if the project is perceived as not genuine, Leadbeater, as a key player from its inception, must have either actively deceived others (Smythe and Landau) or was deceived himself, either by his own doing (Gardner) or by others (Steiner).

4. All persons believing the project had failed are critical of Krishnamurti’s teachings, except for Michel and Bailey (who is not giving an opinion at all), and all persons who regard the project successful, agree with Krishnamurti, except for Luntz. This suggests, contrary to what one might expect, that the positions in themselves do not imply a specific evaluation of Krishnamurti’s teachings: regarding the project as failed does not imply rejection of Krishnamurti’s teachings and regarding the project as successful does not imply agreement.

5. There is a tendency with the only two female presidents of the Theosophical Society, Besant and Burnier, to keep the Theosophical family together by acknowledging Krishnamurti as the messiah and reconciling his teachings with Theosophy.

6. All claimants of contact with the Adepts (Leadbeater, Hodson, Bailey, Ballard and Prophet) could be classified as belonging to position two, i.e. the project was genuine, but failed. Krishnamurti’s denouncement of the Masters, who allegedly backed him in the beginning, must have been reciprocated.

7. There is no consensus between the three alleged clairvoyants: Leadbeater and Hodson adhering to position two and Steiner to position three. Looking for evaluations of each others’ clairvoyancy I found that Steiner challenged Leadbeater’s clairvoyancy and Hodson, in a different context, defended it. (84) Two clairvoyants do see the same things regarding Krishnamurti, another does not.

8. In the cases of direct or indirect reactions by Krishnamurti to some of the views presented (Luntz, Scott and Sloss) Krishnamurti did not react to the specifics of the charges made, but rather reacted with ad hominem arguments, questioning the conscious or subconscious motivations of the person or persons holding those views. Whether fallacious or not, this technique is not uncharacteristic of Krishnamurti and is applied in harmony with his philosophy.

Some remarks about Krishnamurti’s influence might be appropriate here. For many Theosophists Krishnamurti’s metaphysical status was not only an interesting subject for discussion, but one with implications regarding one’s individual perception of and, consequently, membership in the Theosophical Society. The question arises how important the different perceptions of Krishnamurti are to the way the Theosophical Movement, and to a certain extent the New Age Movement also, has developed and is organizationally structured. Steiner’s career alone illustrates sufficiently the importance of this question.

About the future one can safely state that, because the subject of Krishnamurti’s metaphysical status has not yet been exhaustively researched, articles discussing the pros and cons of the different positions will keep the ink flowing and web-sites busy. Probably polite polemical exchanges will flare up periodically, as they did around 1911, when the Order of the Star was founded, or 1929, when it was dissolved, or 1963, when Gardner’s article was published. Also some interesting views were published in 1975. Most prominent was the publication of Mary Lutyens’ biography about Krishnamurti’s formative years. This prompted Krishnamurti to make some extraordinary statements about himself as reproduced in this paper. In the same year, after a long silence about Krishnamurti, the Masters Morya and Kuthumi gave another evaluation of their erstwhile pupil through their alleged messenger Elizabeth Clare Prophet. What was missing that year and might have been reasonably expected, was a Theosophical discussion about Blavatsky’s prophesied “torch-bearer of Truth,” expected in the last quarter of this century. So far Theosophists have been rather silent about this prophecy.

The current controversy over Radha Sloss’ book is of a different order. The subject is mainly about Krishnamurti’s human side, but it provides facts and observations relevant for a more nuanced evaluation of his metaphysical status. For that reason it might well be that this controversy about Krishnamurti’s human side might have as a side-effect a discussion about his metaphysical status.

This paper takes a historical perspective and does not imply a normative judgement about the truth or falsity of the content of the presented views. That question, which is ultimately a matter of personal belief, belongs to the realm of Theosophical theology and not to the realm of academic study of the history of Theosophy. Still I end this paper with two proposals relative to the realm of Theosophical theology.

During the research for this paper I expected to find a comparative study, from a Theosophical point of view, of the teachings of Blavatsky and Krishnamurti. Besides some speculative statements, generalizations, and interesting tidbits in Theosophical literature, I found only one substantial article based on original research. (85) More comparative studies would probably satisfy a still silent demand.

Based on a historical, comparative study of the different Theosophical views on Krishnamurti as a preliminary and necessary work, it would be appropriate to develop a comprehensive Theosophical hypothesis about Krishnamurti. This hypothesis might correspond with or transcend one or more of the above presented views, maybe even combine some of them, explain others, refute critics and incorporate, besides recently discovered facts, the conclusions of comparative studies referred to in the previous paragraph. A tall order, perhaps, but not impossible.

© 1997 by James Santucci. All rights reserved

* * * *

Endnotes

  1. For an overview of the many activities organized during the centenary of Krishnamurti’s birth see The Krishnamurti Foundation of America Newsletter, 10\1 (Spring 1996), 3. (↩)
  2. Arthur H.Nethercot, The Last four Lives of Annie Besant (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1963), 128. (↩)
  3. In the cases of Jean Overton Fuller and Rom Landau an exception was made. Though the point of view they contribute is not their own, I trust that they had correctly reported the views of their sources. (↩)
  4. Mary Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Fulfillment (New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1983), 186,225-228 and 234. (↩)
  5. Ibid., 186, 225-28 and 234. (↩)
  6. Mary Lutyens, Krishnamurti: His Life and Death (New York: St.Martin’s Press, 1991), 83-84. Wherever words and sentences are printed in italics, they were found as such in the original text. (↩)
  7. Ibid., 151. (↩)
  8. J.Krishnamurti, Truth and Actuality (London: Victor Gollancz, 1977), 88. (↩)
  9. Pupul Jayakar, Krishnamurti: A Biography (New York: Harper & Row, 1986), 379. (↩)
  10. H.P.Blavatsky, The Key to Theosophy (Pasadena, Cal.: Theosophical University Press, 1946), 307. (↩) (full text of relevant chapter)
  11. M.H.Charles, “The T.S. as a Herald,” letter to The Vâhan 21\7 (February 1912), 144. (↩)
  12. Annie Besant, “Freedom of Opinion in the T.S.,” letter to The Vâhan 21\8 (March 1912): 153. See also her defense against the charges that she was teaching “Neo-Theosophy” and not Theosophy as taught by Blavatsky: Annie Besant, “The Growth of the T.S.,” The Theosophist 33\10 (July 1912): 506-509. (↩)
  13. A.P.Warrington, “On the Watchtower,” The Theosophist 55\8 (May 1934), 122. (↩)
  14. Mary Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Awakening. (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1975), 255. (↩)
  15. Nethercot, 409. (↩)
  16. Annie Besant, “To Members of the Theosophical Society,” The Theosophist 51\6 (March 1930): 533. (↩)
  17. Catherine Lowman Wessinger, Annie Besant and Progressive Messianism (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press, 1988), 318. Dr.Wessinger gave me valuable editorial help in writing this article, for which I am very grateful. (↩)
  18. Besant, “To Members of the Theosophical Society,” 535. (↩)
  19. Charles E.Luntz, “The Great Testing: A New Theory Regarding Krishnamurti and His Teaching,” The Theosophical Messenger 18\9 (September 1930): 193-197. (↩)
  20. J.Krishnamurti, The Art of Listening, vol.1 (1933-1934), The Collected Works of J.Krishnamurti (Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt, 1991), 173. (↩)
  21. Pupul Jayakar, 379-380, and Radha Rajagopal Sloss, Lives in the Shadow with J.Krishnamurti (New York: Addison-Wesley, 1991), 306. (↩)
  22. The Theosophist 107\6 (March 1986) and 116\8 (May 1995). (↩)
  23. Radha Burnier, “J.Krishnamurti,” The Theosophist 107\6 (March 1986): 203. (↩)
  24. Jean Overton Fuller, “Krishnamurti,” Theosophical History 1\6 (April 1986): 140-141. (↩)
  25. Gregory Tillett, The Elder Brother: A Biography of Charles Webster Leadbeater (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1982), 273. (↩)
  26. Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Fulfillment, 226 and 230. (↩)
  27. Ernest Wood, “`No Religion Higher Than Truth,'” The American Theosophist 52\12 (December 1964): 288. (↩) (full text of article)
  28. Ibid., 289. (↩)
  29. C.W.Leadbeater, “Art Thou He That Should Come?,” The Theosophist 51\9 (June 1930): 472. (↩)
  30. Adrian G.Vreede, “An Attack on Bishop Leadbeater,” The Liberal Catholic 34\7 (February 1964): 150. (↩)
  31. Tillett, 218. (↩)
  32. Nethercot, 368. See pp.362-369 for more details on this episode. (↩)
  33. Vreede: 150. (↩)
  34. Geoffrey Hodson, Thus Have I Heard: A Book of Spiritual and Occult Gleanings from the Teachings of the Great (Adyar, India: Theosophical Publishing House, 1929), 101-111. (↩) (full text of relevant chapter)
  35. John K. Robertson, “Aquarian Occultist: The Life and Teachings of Geoffrey Hodson” (unpublished MS, 1971), 190-198. Copy of relevant chapter provided by German author Peter Michel. (↩)
  36. Peter Michel, Krishnamurti: Love and Freedom–Approaching a Mystery (Woodside, CA: Bluestar Communications, 1995), 33. (↩)
  37. Sandra Hodson, ed., Light of the Sanctuary: The Occult Diary of Geoffrey Hodson (Manila: Theosophical Publishing House, 1988). (↩)
  38. Geoffrey Hodson, Krishnamurti and the Search for Light (Sydney: St.Alban Press, n.d.), 9. According to the Supplement to a Bibliography of the Life and Teachings of J.Krishnamurti (Bombay: Chetana, 1982) by Susunaga Weeraperuma there exists a reply to Hodson’s booklet by E.F.D.Bertram, titled “Krishnamurti and the Search for Light–A Reply to Mr.Hodson’s Attack.” (↩)
  39. Robertson, 190-191. (↩)
  40. His Pupil [Cyril Scott], The Initiate (London: Routledge, 1920); The Initiate in the New World (London: Routledge, 1927); The Initiate in the Dark Cycle (London: Routledge,1932). (↩)
  41. Cyril Scott, Outline of Modern Occultism (London: Routledge, 1935), 232. (↩)
  42. Chapter 5, “Krishnamurti: a Problem,” 65-77, and chapter 11, “The Truth about Krishnamurti,” 133-143. (↩)
  43. Scott, Outline of Modern Occultism, 233. (↩)
  44. Scott, The Initiate in the Dark Cycle, 137-138, 141, and 143. (↩)
  45. J.Krishnamurti, Early Talks IV, (Bombay: Chetena, 1972), 100. Second talk at Eddington, Pennsylvania, June 14, 1936. (↩)
  46. Scott, Initiate in the Dark Cycle, 143. (↩)
  47. David Tame, The Secret Power of Music (Rochester, VT: Destiny Books, 1984), 265. (↩)
  48. David Anrias, Adepts of the Five Elements (London: Routledge, 1933), xii. (↩)
  49. David Anrias, Through the Eyes of the Masters: Meditations and Portraits (London: Routledge, 1932), 65-69. (↩)
  50. Alice Bailey, Discipleship in the New Age, vol.2 (New York: Lucis Trust, 1955), 171. (↩)
  51. For a basic overview of the history and teachings of the I AM Movement see Charles S.Braden, These Also Believe: A Study of Modern American Cults and Minority Religious Movements (New York: Macmillan, 1949), 257-307. (↩)
  52. Kuthumi, “Kuthumi’s Discourse,” in Ascended Master Light (Schaumburg, Il: Saint Germain Press, 1938), 316-317 and 323. (↩)
  53. Robert S. Ellwood Jr., Religious and Spiritual Groups in Modern America (Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall, 1973), 121. (↩)
  54. J.Krishnamurti, “The Dissolution of the Order of the Star,” International Star Bulletin (September 1929): 34. (↩)
  55. J.Gordon Melton, “The Church Universal and Triumphant: Its Heritage and Thoughtworld,” in Church Universal and Triumphant In Scholarly Perspective, eds. J.R.Lewis and J.Gordon Melton (Stanford: Center for Academic Publication, 1994), 1-20. (↩)
  56. Richard Singelenberg, Ariane Brederode and Henrice Wittenhorst, “Het Orakel van Uncle Sam: Een schets van Summit Lighthouse” in Religieuze bewegingen in Nederland 16 (Summer 1988): 83. (↩)
  57. Kuthumi, “An Exposé of False Teachings,” Pearls of Wisdom 19\5 (1 February 1976): 28. (Relevant Paragraphs) (↩)
  58. El Morya, The Chela and the Path–Meeting the Challenge of Life in the Twentieth Century (Malibu CA: Summit University Press, 1975), 121-122. (Relevant Paragraphs) (↩)
  59. El Morya, 122. (↩)
  60. Michel, 25 and 40. (↩)
  61. Peter Michel, personal letter, 18 August 1995. (↩)
  62. Thomas H. Meyer, The Bodhisattva Question: Krishnamurti, Rudolf Steiner, Annie Besant, Valentin Tomberg, and the Mystery of the Twentieth-Century Master (London: Temple Lodge, 1993), 54-56. This study, pro-anthroposophical and well-referenced, contains valuable contributions towards understanding Steiner’s thoughts and actions in connection with the Theosophical Society, the Order of the Star in the East and the founding of his own Anthroposophical Society. (↩)
  63. Rudolf Steiner, “Bodhisattvas, Buddhas and Christ,” in From Jesus to Christ (London: Rudolf Steiner Press, 1973), 44-47,170 and 176. Lecture given in Milan, Italy, 21 September 1911. (↩)
  64. Ibid., 179-180. (↩)
  65. Rudolf Steiner, The Story of my Life (London: Anthroposophical Publishing Co., 1928), 300. (↩)
  66. Rudolf Steiner, “Das Russische Volkstum,” in Der Zusammenhang des Menschen mit der elementarischen Welt (Dornach, Switzerland: Rudolf Steiner-Nachlassverwaltung, 1986), 197 and 201. Address given in Helsingfors, Finland, April 11, 1912. Translations of quotes taken from Meyer, 43-44. (↩)
  67. For more on Steiner’s perception of Theosophy see the articles by H.J.Spierenburg: “Dr.Steiner on H.P.B.,” Theosophical History 1\7 (July 1986): 159-174. “Dr. Rudolf Steiner on the Mahatmas,” part 1, Theosophical History 1\8 (October 1986): 211-223, and part 2, Theosophical History 2\1 (January 1987): 23-31. (↩)
  68. Albert E.S.Smythe, “The Messianic Craze,” Hamilton Herald, 11 November 1931. Transcribed for the author from a clipping in the archives of the Hamilton Theosophical Society in Ontario, Canada, by Mr. Ted Davy. (↩)
  69. E.L.Gardner, There Is No Religion Higher Than Truth: Developments in the Theosophical Society (London: Theosophical Publishing House, 1963), 9-17. Gregory Tillett provided an overview of the discussion. See Tillett, 274-278.
    {A collection of responses to Gardner’s theory can be found in: Hodson, Sandra; van Thiel, Mathias (eds.) C.W. Leadbeater: A Great Occultist (n.p.: the editors, n.d. [ca. 1965]). The divergence of views is well illustrated by a review and subsequent discussion in the Dutch Theosophical magazine Theosofia. See review by A.J.H. van Leeuwen and response by W.C. Burger in respectively the January and March 1964 issues.} (↩)
  70. Tillett, 276. (↩)
  71. Gardner, 8-9. (↩)
  72. Rom Landau, God is my Adventure (London: Nicholson & Watson, 1935), 100. (↩)
  73. Nethercot, 450. (↩)
  74. Letter from Mary Lutyens to Arthur Nethercot, 31 May 1961, in Nethercot, 450, n.9. (↩)
  75. Sloss, 314 and 315. (↩)
  76. To counter the allegations made in Sloss’ book the KFA mounted a defense to present their side of the conflict. See: Krishnamurti Foundation of America, Statement by the Krishnamurti Foundation of America about the Radha Sloss book “Lives in the shadow with J.Krishnamurti” (Ojai, CA: KFA, n.d.); Erna Lilliefelt, KFA History–Report on the Formation of Krishnamurti Foundation of America and the Lawsuits Which Took Place between 1968 and 1986 to Recover Assets for Krishnamurti’s Work (Ojai, CA: KFA, 1995); and Mary Lutyens, Krishnamurti and the Rajagopals (Ojai, CA: KFA, 1996). (↩)
  77. Sloss, 294, 295, 300 and 301. (↩)
  78. Statement by the Krishnamurti Foundation… etc., 9-11. (↩)
  79. John Algeo, review of Krishnamurti–Love and Freedom by Peter Michel in Quest 8\3 (Autumn 1995): 86-87. (↩)
  80. Sloss, 303. (↩)
  81. Algeo, 87. (↩)
  82. Conversation with John Algeo, February 20, 1996. (↩)
  83. Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Fulfillment, 228 and 229. (↩)
  84. For Steiner on Leadbeater see: Meyer, 46. For Hodson on Leadbeater see: Sandra Hodson and Mathias van Thiel (eds.), C.W.Leadbeater: A Great Occultist (n.p.: the editors, n.d.), 1-2. Scott could have been included as a clairvoyant, but is not, because he does not explicitly claim that his writings are based on clairvoyancy. (↩)
  85. Aryel Sanat, “The Secret Doctrine, Krishnamurti & Transformation,” The American Theosophist 76\5 (May 1988), 133-143. In a biographical sidebar in the article it is mentioned that the author was working on a book “exploring connections between Krishnamurti, the Mahatmas, and Buddhism,” which has not yet been published. ↩
  86. [A longer version of the article can be found on the internet and Quest Books published in 1999 his The Inner Life of Krishnamurti: Private Passion and Perennial Wisdom.] (↩)

The Masters and Their Emissaries: From H.P.B. to Guru Ma and Beyond

By Govert Schuller

On September 7, 1875, Helena Petrovna Blavatsky and Henry Steel Olcott founded the Theosophical Society. They were directed to do so by two eastern Adepts or Masters, Morya and Koot Hoomi.(1)  Besides its three official objects (1a), the mission of the Theosophical Society was to prepare the world for the coming of a great spiritual teacher, expected in the last quarter of the 20th century.(2)

Annie Besant, Blavatsky s successor as leader of the Theosophical Society, and Charles Webster Leadbeater, mediator between the Adepts and the Theosophical Society, were directed to implement this project fifty years in advance.(3)  The young Jiddu Krishnamurti was chosen and trained to be the vehicle through whom the World Teacher Lord Maitreya would reveal himself.(4)  The Order of the Star in the East was the worldwide organization to draw together all those who expected the coming of this great teacher. Krishnamurti became its Head. Not all Theosophists were in agreement with these developments.(5)  Until about 1927 all went relatively well(6) and starting on December 28, 1925 Krishnamurti was overshadowed a few times by Lord Maitreya.(7) Krishnamurti and other Theosophists declared the project successful,(8) others were of the opposite opinion.(9)  From about 1927 on Krishnamurti decided to go his own way and irrevocably dissociated himself from the project by dissolving the Order of the Star on August 3, 1929.

Through Theosophists Cyril Scott and David Anrias, the Adepts communicated their evaluation of the project and declared it an almost complete failure.(10)   Krishnamurti caused so much confusion in the ranks of the Theosophists, that the Theosophical Society was disqualified as the spearhead of the work of the Adepts.  Nevertheless, some Theosophists, such as C. Jinarajadasa and Geoffrey Hodson, were still in contact with the Adepts(11), and They kept a continuing interest in the affairs of the Theosophical Society.(12)  Furthermore the Adepts worked also with Alice Bailey, which was not successful (13), and with Nicholas and Helena Roerich, which was.(14)

Three months after Krishnamurti had dissolved the Order of the Star, the crash on the New York Stock Exchange happened.  This event was the starting point of an unprecedented disastrous sixteen-year-cycle of economic depression, militarism, fascism and war, culminating in the Holocaust and the use of the atomic bomb.  This was no coincidence. One of its main causes was the earlier mentioned confusion amongst many advanced souls.   They were not able anymore to keep the forces of darkness at bay.(15)

In the summer of 1930, the Adept Saint Germain approached Guy Ballard, an American mining engineer with an interest in the occult, with the request to become messenger for the Adepts.  Ballard wrote Unveiled Mysteries under the name Godfre Ray King and founded the I AM Movement.(16)  Through Ballard the Adepts gave the revelations deemed necessary for the Age of Aquarius, which originally were intended to be given through Krishnamurti.(17)   These revelations included original teachings about mantra yoga, the divine self or the I AM Presence, and the initiation of the ascension.(18)   In the 1930s the I AM Movement was very successful.(19)   Because of Guy Ballard s passing in 1939, a string of lawsuits and bad publicity, the movement experienced a setback. Guy Ballard s wife, Edna Ballard, succeeded him.

In 1944 the Adept the Maha Chohan, the chief of El Morya and Kuthumi, contacted I AM member Geraldine Innocente.(20)  In April 1952 she founded anonymously the Bridge to Freedom to spread some teachings by Thomas Printz, pseudonym for El Morya.(21)

Mark Prophet, who was associated with the Bridge to Freedom, was contacted by El Morya in the early 1950s.  The Adepts directed him to found The Summit Lighthouse, which he did on August 8, 1958.  This organization, now also known as Church Universal and Triumphant, has been a very successful organization in spreading the revelations for the New Age of Aquarius.(22)   Its current head is Elizabeth Clare Prophet, who was contacted in the spring of 1961 by El Morya to join The Summit Lighthouse in order to be trained as a messenger.(23)  She became its head in 1973 after the passing of Mark Prophet to whom she was married.(24)   Among her students she is also known as Guru Ma or just Mother.  In 1997 the organization lost its protection from El Morya (24a) and unfortunately, in late 1998, Prophet was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease and soon after stopped transmitting messages from the Masters.

Recent offshoots of Church Universal and Triumphant are The Temple of The Presence founded by Carolyn and Monroe Shearer; Ask the Real Jesus by Kim Michaels and Shangra-la by Lorraine Michaels; New Wisdom University by Marsha Covington; and The Hearts Center by David Lewis. All were members of Prophet’s organization and claim to be contacted by the Masters to inaugurate new Ascended Master organizations. (25)

The revelations given through the Ballards and the Prophets on one side, and the philosophy of Krishnamurti (and others) on the other side might both lead to either the beginning of a transformation of already existing civilizations like the Judeo-Christian and the Indic, both of which might be stimulated to new levels of intellectual and spiritual development, or–and this probably being the case with Krishnamurti s teachings–to the birth of a completely new, though deeply flawed, religion and civilization.(26)

[As of 2014, the Theosophical views in this article have been suspended. See here for a more critical, secular view]

1. El Morya wrote in 1882:

So casting about we found in America the man [H.S. Olcott] to stand as leader… . With him we associated a woman [H.P. Blavatsky] of most exceptional and wonderful endowments… . We sent her to America, brought them together–and the trial began. Letter No.44, Morya to A.P. Sinnett, February 1882, in A.T. Barker, compiler, The Mahatma Letters to A.P. Sinnett (Adyar, India: Theosophical Publishing House, 1972), p. 259.

And in 1975:

In 1876, Helena Petrovna Blavatsky was ordered by the Master Kuthumi and me, then known as the Masters K.H. and M., to write Isis Unveiled. Later she was given the responsibility of imparting The Secret Doctrine to the world. El Morya, The Chela and the Path (Corwin Springs MT: Summit University Press, 1975), p. 122.

[Quotes in notes 1, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 23 and 24 were reprinted with permission from the publisher. Copyright 1975, 1976, 1979, 1980, 1994, Summit University Press, P.O. Box 5000, Corwin Springs, Montana 59030-5000. (406) 848-9500. Web site: http://www.tsl.org].

Both Masters took their fifth initiation, the Ascension, at the close of the last century, thereby becoming incorporeal Ascended Masters. And as Blavatsky has written–referring to other saints, that, when unburthened of their terrestrial tabernacles, their freed souls, henceforth united forever with their spirits, rejoin the whole shining host, which is bound together in one spiritual solidarity of thought and deed, and called the anointed, –the same glad tidings could be told, not only about these two illustrious Masters, but also about many other brave souls who followed them. [H.P. Blavatsky, Isis Unveiled (Pasadena CA: Theosophical University Press, 1976 [1877]), II, p. 159]. For practical purposes the difference between an Unascended Master and an Ascended one is not very great. Both can work in the physical as well as in the spiritual realm and both have a wide array of occult powers at their command to guide Their pupils and help mankind. The difference is that an Unascended Master has its base of operations in a physical body and an Ascended Master in a spiritual body. To dismiss the latter as spooks, because They do not conform to one s idea of flesh-and-blood Masters, is to deny oneself the great wisdom coming from the ‘anointed’ or Ascended Masters. 

[Blavatsky wrote about the concept of Nirmanakaya:

“As a Nirmanakaya, however, the adept leaves behind him only his physical body, and retains every other “principle” save the Kamic, for he has crushed this out for ever from his nature during life, and it can never resurrect in his post-mortem state. Thus, instead of going into selfish bliss, he chooses a life of self-sacrifice, an existence which ends only with the life-cycle, in order to be enabled to help mankind in an invisible, yet most effective, manner.”

The Key to Theosophy (London: Theosophical Publishing Co., 1889), pp. 353-354]

Return to Text

1a. The objects of the Theosophical Society are the following:



  1. To form a nucleus of the universal brotherhood of humanity, without distinction of race, creed, sex, caste, or color.




  2. To encourage the comparative study of religion, philosophy, and science.




  3. To investigate unexplained laws of nature and the powers latent in humanity.



Return to Text

2. Blavatsky wrote in 1889:

If the present attempt, in the form of our Society, succeeds better than its predecessors have done, then it will be in existence as an organized, living and healthy body when the time comes for the effort of the XXth century. The general condition of men s minds and hearts will have been improved and purified by the spread of its teachings, and, as I have said, their prejudices and dogmatic illusions will have been, to some extent at least, removed. Not only so, but besides a large and accessible literature ready to men s hands, the next impulse will find a numerous and united body of people ready to welcome the new torch-bearer of Truth. He will find the minds of men prepared for his message, a language ready for him in which to clothe the new truths he brings, an organization awaiting his arrival, which will remove the merely mechanical, material obstacles and difficulties from his path. Think how much one, to whom such an opportunity is given, could accomplish. Measure it by comparison with what the Theosophical Society actually has achieved in the last fourteen years, with out any of these advantages and surrounded by hosts of hindrances which would not hamper the new leader. Consider all this, and then tell me whether I am too sanguine when I say that if the Theosophical Society survives and lives true to its mission, to its original impulses through the next hundred years–tell me, I say, if I go too far in asserting that earth will be a heaven in the twenty-first century in comparison with what it is now!

H.P. Blavatsky, The Key to Theosophy (London: Theosophical Publishing Co., 1889), pp. 306-307.

Return to Text

3. Annie Besant wrote in 1912:

It may interest members to recall the fact that Mme. H.P. Blavatsky, one of the founders of the T.S., regarded it as the mission of the T.S. to prepare the world for the coming of the next great Teacher, though she put that event perhaps half a century later than I do. Which of us is right as to date, only time can show. I do not say that she was necessarily right in making this its mission, but as she proclaimed this view in the supposedly uncolored days, under the old r gime, the repetition of the statement by myself does not imply any change of policy. She wrote: The next impulse will find a numerous and united body of people ready to welcome the new torch-bearer of Truth. He will find the minds of men prepared for his message, a language ready for him in which to clothe the new truths he brings, an organization awaiting his arrival, which will remove the merely mechanical, material obstacles and difficulties from his path. That was the view of one of our Founders–really of both–as to the future of the Theosophical Society, and my crime is that I share it, and do what my poor powers permit in preparing the minds of men for that coming.

Annie Besant, Freedom of Opinion in the T.S., letter to The V han 21\8 (March 1912), p. 153.

Return to Text

4. Shortly after meeting Krishna for the first time, Leadbeater revealed to [Theosophist Ernest] Wood that the boy was to be the vehicle for the Lord Maitreya unless something went wrong and that he, Leadbeater, had been directed to help train him for that purpose.

Mary Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Awakening, (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1975), p. 21.

Return to Text

5. In particular the German Section of the Theosophical Society, led by Rudolf Steiner, expressed its intolerance towards members of the Order of the Star, by stating that membership of both organizations was mutually exclusive. This policy was obviously contrary to the principle of freedom of thought and association, a cornerstone of the Theosophical Society. The defiant stand taken on this issue by the German Section led eventually to the cancellation of their charter.

Return to Text

6. During the Jubilee Convention of the Theosophical Society in 1925 a message originating from an Adept was read to the participants. This happened a few days before December 28, when the first overshadowing of Krishnamurti by the Lord Maitreya occurred. A part of the message reads:

A second half-century of fine promise lies before you. We say to you: You have the power to do more in the immediate future than any other body of men and women has ever achieved before. We say to you: Within this next half century you can make Brotherhood a living reality in the world. You can cause the warring classes, castes, and nations to cease their quarreling, the warring faiths to live once more in brotherhood, respect and understanding. Make Theosophy a living force in your lives, and through your example those class and caste distinctions, which for so long have bred hatred and misery, shall at no distant time come to be but distinctions of function in the common service of the nation-family and of the World-Brotherhood… .”

“It is the Law that Our Blessed Lord comes among you, be His welcome what it may, though even he may not outstay His welcome. And only at long intervals, so far, has He been able to bestow upon you the priceless benediction of His immediate presence in your midst. We have to wait. So be it. Yet, if His welcome lasts, perchance grows, He may dwell long with you, and the doors thus be flung wide open between Our world and your, and between other worlds and yours, that they may become one world, Ourselves restored to Our natural place among Our younger comrades, and Devas and mankind be once more together in happy comradeship.

Anonymous Master, A Message to the Members of the Theosophical Society from an Elder Brother, The Theosophist 47\4 (January 1926), supplement, pp. 3 and 4. And what did Krishnamurti do? Instead of opening, he slammed the door in Their face.

Return to Text

7. Geoffrey Hodson wrote in 1927:

As he [Krishnamurti] speaks, the spirit of the Christ descends, as a great collective inspiration, into the hearts and minds of all. It draws nearer and nearer in a great ring-shaped cloud of golden light. It hovers over our heads, descends still lower, slowly and gently, like a warm summer rain, till all are enwrapped in its beauty, its peace and all-compelling love… . Night after night, as he ceases to speak, a miracle occurs. Two thousand sevenhundred people remain perfectly still. In that silence the splendor of splendors is revealed to the inner eyes. The figure of the Lord appears above the head of Krishnaji. The silence deepens. We are enfolded in His embrace, filled with tenderness and compassion as he draws near.

Geoffrey Hodson, Thus Have I Heard (Adyar, India: Theosophical Publishing House, 1929), pp. 107-108.

Leadbeater wrote in 1930:

This is He who should come, and there is no need to look elsewhere; as I have said, I know that the World-Teacher often speaks through Krishnaji, but I also know that there are occasions when He does not.

C.W. Leadbeater, Art Thou He That Should Come? The Theosophist 51\9 (June 1930), p. 472.

Return to Text

8. Krishnamurti wrote in 1927:

I know my destiny and my work. I know with certainty and knowledge of my own, that I am blending into the consciousness of the one Teacher and that He will completely fill me.

Letter from Krishnamurti to Leadbeater February 9, 1927, quoted in Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Awakening, p. 241.

I never said: I am the World Teacher; but now that I feel I am one with my Beloved, I say it.

Talk by Krishnamurti, August 2, 1927, quoted in Lutyens, p. 250.

Annie Besant declared in 1927:

The Divine Spirit has descended once more on a man, Krishnamurti, one who in his life is literally perfect, as those who know him can testify… . The World Teacher is here.

Annie Besant, The Way of Sorrows and the Way of Happiness: The New Message The Theosophist 48/7 (April 1927), p. 6d.

Return to Text

9. I had a talk with [Theosophist] Jinarajadasa, who staggered me by saying that the gathering at Eerde [in August 1927] had been a tragedy and a failure and had almost wrecked the Plan of the Brotherhood.

Lady Emily Lutyens, Candles in the Sun (London: Rupert Hart-Davis, 1957), p. 163.

C.W.L. declared privately when in Adyar in 1927 that The Coming had gone wrong.

Adrian G. Vreede, An Attack on Bishop Leadbeater, The Liberal Catholic 34\7 (February 1964), p. 150.

Return to Text

10. [His mission was] a success while still overshadowed by the world-Teacher,.. a failure afterwards.

An English Master, Sir Thomas in His Pupil [Cyril Scott], The Initiate in the Dark Cycle (London: Routledge, 1932), p. 141.

It became all but impossible for him to be used any longer as my medium.

Lord Maitreya in David Anrias [Brian Ross], Through the Eyes of the Masters: Meditations and Portraits (London: Routledge, 1932), p. 66.

For a metaphysical critique of Krishnamurti s teachings see  Krishnamurti: An Esoteric View of his Teachings.

Return to Text

11. State how… you received the information from Brother Jinarajadasa–Our Agent at that time–affirming that he had passed the Initiation during the night that preceded your experience on waking, at Mt Maunganui.

Message from Master Polidorus Isurenus, June 30, 1975, to Geoffrey Hodson in Sandra Hodson (Comp.), Light of the Sanctuary: The Occult Diary of Geoffrey Hodson (Manila, Philippines: The Theosophical Publisher, 1988), p. 265.

Return to Text

12. The Master M. [El Morya] and K.H. [Kuthumi] together with the Maha Sahib [the Maha Chohan] will renew the hundred-year cycle of their service through the chelas at Adyar [the international headquarters of the Theosophical Society].

Goddess of Liberty, The Mutable Soul is Entrusted with the Immutable Spirit, Pearls of Wisdom 23/12 (March 23, 1980), p. 66.

But the backing does not come without critical evaluation: Look at those who have had the dispensation of the Ascended Masters in the Theosophical Society, the Rosicrucian Order, the Agni Yoga Society, the I AM movement and other forward movements that have begun to unveil the presence and teachings of great adepts in the earth. Look at the members of these organizations, beloved. Some have almost become intellectual snobs, for they do not use the teachings to challenge the forces of Darkness in the earth but only to elevate themselves as the wise ones, for they have such and such teaching that other earthlings do not have. This was never the Brotherhood s intent in the founding of esoteric organizations.

Mighty Victory, Becoming more of God Day by Day, Pearls of Wisdom 37/32 (August 7, 1994), pp. 376-377.

Return to Text

13. Kuthumi wrote in 1975:

In the past we have had to withdraw our support from those who were given the opportunity to represent us. The one who for a time had the opportunity of representing the master Djwal Kul soon lost that authority through intellectual pride and the brittleness of the lower mental body, which can never be the channel of the mind of God. Thus I expose to you the false teachings subtly woven into the work of Alice Bailey, whose failure to surrender totally rendered her unfit as an instrument of the Tibetan Master.

Kuthumi, An Expos of False Teachings Pearls of Wisdom 19/5 (February 1, 1976), p. 28. (Relevant Paragraphs)

Return to Text

14. The Roerichs set forth the word of Morya destined to reach both the Russian and the American people with the energy and the enlightenment that should deter the red dragon of World Communism.

El Morya, The Chela and the Path, p. 122. (Relevant Paragraphs)

Return to Text

15. Thus the stage was left for all kinds of black magicians and their ilk to play out their nefarious plots. Chief amongst them were the German Nazis, whose involvement in the occult and borrowing from Theosophy has been well documented. See for example Nicholas Goodrick Clarke, The Occult Roots of Nazism (New York: New York University Press, 1985); Dusty Sklar, The Nazis and the Occult (New York: Dorset Press, 1977); and the more speculative, but from an esoteric point of view more interesting, The Spear of Destiny (New York: Putnam, 1973) by Trevor Ravenscroft. The contrast between the expectations for humankind as presented in endnotes 2 and 6, and what actually happened indicates that we have to face up to a tragedy of immense proportions.

Return to Text

16. For a basic overview of the history and teachings of the I AM Movement see Charles S. Braden, These Also Believe: A Study of Modern American Cults and Minority Religious Movements (New York: Macmillan, 1949), pp. 257-307.

Return to Text

17. This is the pivotal statement connecting on one side the story of the Adepts involvement with the Theosophical Society and Krishnamurti from 1875 till 1929, and on the other side the story of Their involvement with the Ballards, Innocente and the Prophets from 1930 till the present. The rationale of the Masters changing allegiance to their embodied representatives is as follows:

The Ascended Masters are the authority of the true teacher and the true messenger. We release the energy, the light, the teaching, the initiations, and the discipline to and through our representatives. If at any time the teacher or the messenger who has surrendered his human will to the divine will should elect to take back that human will, our dispensation will terminate. The light…would be withdrawn and the trained disciple would receive the certain sign of hierarchy that the instrument had become a dry reed, hollow and without the authentic vibration and backing of the entire Spirit of the Great White Brotherhood… . Stand beneath the waterfall and receive unreservedly the flow of the hierarchy of Aquarius that comes through our embodied messengers. When the waterfall ceases to flow, move on, for hierarchy will not be stopped. We will open another stream and prepare a channel for the crystal-clear waters of life.

Kuthumi, An Expos of False Teachings, Pearls of Wisdom 19/5 (February 1, 1976), p. 29. (Relevant Paragraphs)

Return to Text

18. In the 1930s came the twin flames Guy W. Ballard and Edna Ballard imparting the sacred mystery of the law of the I AM, further knowledge of hierarchy, the invocation of the sacred fire, and the path of the ascension.

El Morya, The Chela and the Path, p. 122. (Relevant Paragraphs)

Return to Text

19. At its apex in the late thirties, it must have represented the greatest popular diffusion Theosophical concepts ever attained… . One cannot but admire the effectiveness with which Ballard presented in a truly popular and American manner the basic teaching and sense of wonder which underlies Theosophy.

Robert S. Ellwood, Jr., Religious and Spiritual Groups in Modern America (Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall, 1973), p. 121.

Return to Text

20. J. Gordon Melton, The Church Universal and Triumphant: Its Heritage and Thoughtworld, in Church Universal and Triumphant In Scholarly Perspective, edited by. J.R. Lewis and J. Gordon Melton (Stanford: Center for Academic Publication, 1994), pp. 13-14.

Return to Text

21. El Morya wrote in 1954:

The condition of the consciousness of seekers after Truth warranted the opportunity to find peace in the comradeship of the Masters, without homage to personality. It was my thought to give such opportunity, letting the balm of the Presence, the joy of the Masters friendship and the freedom of conscience which such an Open Door would allow, to flow freely to all life, without requiring allegiance to any human form.

Thomas Printz (El Morya), The First Ray (Mount Shasta, CA: Ascended Master Teaching Foundation, 1986: originally published by the Bridge to Freedom in 1954), p.31.

Return to Text

22. In an academic study, conducted by a group of religious scholars, some notable conclusions regarding Elizabeth Clare Prophet and Church Universal and Triumphant were presented. In the introduction one can read that many of the contributions to the present volume are shaped by, or at least address, the various accusations that have been leveled against Church Universal and Triumphant over the years. Some of us, and perhaps most of us who participated in the study, brought certain negative stereotypes along with us on our first trip to Montana [where the Church has its headquarters]. Yet, once there, our preconceptions quickly evaporated in the encounter with a group of generally very likable, intelligent, flesh-and-blood human beings. … Beyond simple positive intentions, I think they have managed to establish one of the most intrinsically interesting religious communities to come into being in this century. The range and complexity of their worldview, just to mention one facet of the Church, deserves a half-dozen studies of the length we have undertaken in the present volume.

J.R. Lewis, Introduction, in Church Universal and Triumphant In Scholarly Perspective, pp. xii-xiii.

Return to Text

23. Elizabeth Clare Prophet said in 1979:

Within a matter of a few weeks [after having met Mark Prophet], I was crossing a park to Boston University to one of my courses. And there crossed my path a being of Light that I had never heard of or seen before. But the moment I saw him, I knew him. It was the Ascended Master El Morya… . Morya said to me I have need of a female messenger. Go to Washington and I will train you through Mark Prophet. If you pass your initiations, Saint Germain will come and anoint you as messenger for the Ascended Masters.

Elizabeth Clare Prophet, I m Stumping for the Coming Revolution in Higher Consciousness, Audio-tape no. A7945, (Corwin Springs MT: The Summit Lighthouse, 1979).

Return to Text

24. The History of the Summit Lighthouse (Livingston MT: Church Universal and Triumphant, 1994), p. 4.

Return to Text

24a. El Morya said:

“I, El Morya Khan, Chief of the Darjeeling Council, hereby announce the removal of the thread that originates from my mantle to the heart of the messenger to your hearts for the holding of the balance of your lifestreams. The dispensation of this thread, which is a thread of protection, was made possible because of the codes of conduct established and sponsored by me in the past. Your merit for intercession will now be based upon your own decree momentum, your devotion to your God Presence and your service to mankind. May you pass every test!”

Read by Elizabeth Clare Prophet at a staff meeting on May 13, 1997. [Last sentence added in 2001]

Return to Text

25. For some more background information about these post-Prophet organizations see “Beyond Guru Ma.” [This paragraph was added in 2001 and revised in 2005]

Return to Text

26. For a philosophical-historical discussion of the relationship between religion and civilization, see Arnold J. Toynbee, Universal Churches, vol. 7B, A Study of History (London: Oxford University Press, 1954), pp. 381-544.

Return to Text

Krishnamurti: An Esoteric View of His Teachings

by Govert Schuller

One is opposed to nothing more severely
than to errors recently laid aside
—Goethe

A question which might interest many Theosophists is what Blavatsky and the Masters might have thought about the teachings of Krishnamurti. Although Blavatsky died before Krishnamurti was born, she fortunately left some writings which are helpful in determining on what points her teachings agree and disagree with those of Krishnamurti. The focus will be on their differences because some disagreements pertain directly to the foundations of Krishnamurti’s teachings.(1)

For example, Blavatsky stresses that one cannot pass over even one step on the path to higher consciousness (2), yet Krishnamurti summarily rejects not only a path of graduated levels in attaining truth (3), but also the very existence of a higher self to unite with.(4) Furthermore, Blavatsky makes it clear that a Guru plays an essential part in one’s mastery of higher consciousness (5), while Krishnamurti repudiates the role of a spiritual teacher.(6)

The differences even take a dramatic turn when it becomes clear that Blavatsky seriously warns about the kind of philosophy Krishnamurti teaches. She writes that certain doctrines in exoteric Vedantism–which are very similar to Krishnamurti’s teachings–might have the effect of disconnecting the soul or the personal self from its higher source, the higher self.(7) This in turn might cause the ‘second death’ of the soul, which is like an implosion of consciousness into nothingness (8) as opposed to the ‘second birth’ of the soul when she expands into divinity by first uniting with the higher self and ultimately with the divine self. These differences are not just philosophical and void of spiritual relevance. From an esoteric point of view they are of great significance.

Aside from the serious and grave warnings inferred from Blavatsky’s writings, the Masters themselves made some specific comments on Krishnamurti’s teachings. Lord Maitreya, for example, pointed out that Krishnamurti made a mistake in assuming that anyone could reach his level of consciousness immediately.(9) An English Master indicated that Krishnamurti is teaching an erroneous version of Advaita Vedanta (10), confirming indeed what was gleaned from Blavatsky. Furthermore, this Master warned for some serious dangers in Krishnamurti’s teachings, notably his rejection of an esoteric system of spiritual evaluation and his invitation to intense meditation without occult protection.(11) According to this Master, engaging in Krishnamurti’s brand of Advaitism might lead to hypocrisy and self-delusion.(12) Krishnamurti’s former Guru, Kuthumi, likewise expressed a stern warning about the consequences of his philosophy.(13) Finally, Geoffrey Hodson, a prominent Theosophist and clairvoyant pupil of the Masters, accuses Krishnamurti of circular reasoning (14) and intellectual arrogance.(15) Again, it has to be stressed that these errors are not just a matter of intellectual interest without spiritual consequences. The very health, even survival, of one’s spiritual being is involved here.

Regarding the feasibility of Krishnamurti’s suggestion of a profound fundamental transformation of the human consciousness, it has to be pointed out that Krishnamurti did not arrive at that level of consciousness by way of his own proposed instantaneous‘non- method.’(16) He arrived there solely by treading first the path of initiation under a Master (17)–going almost to its final conclusion–then stepped aside, and denounced the whole method.(18) Furthermore, Vimala Thakar, the only one who executed his kind of transformation in a credible way (19)–and as such could prove its feasability–did not arrive there by his proposed ‘non-method’ either. Instead, she transformed because Krishnamurti acted as Guru to her. She first gradually acquired an experimental understanding of his erroneous brand of Advaita Vedantism and then Krishnamurti, while laying hands on her for healing an auditory ailment, initiated her into his rebellious state of consciousness.(20) To quote Blavatsky, applying Krishnamurti’s ‘non-method’ is “like destroying a bridge over an impassable chasm; The traveler can never reach the goal on the other shore.”(21)

The foregoing does not imply that there are no truthful and salutary insights to be found in Krishnamurti’s teachings. He exhorts people to think for themselves (22) and to change in a fundamental way (23); he skillfully diagnoses certain dangers of the human ego or synthetic self (24); and he invokes with compassion a sense of urgency about the dangerous situation mankind is in.(25) But these pearls have to be found in a sea of errors. If the foundations of his teachings are erroneous then also its superstructure. A well-grounded Theosophical conception of human nature and a mastery of the “abstruse difficulties of Indian metaphysics”(26) are indispensable to catch these pearls. Even then, one might easily trip over the pearls and land in the mire of Krishnamurti’s misconceptions. Due to the deceptive, even mesmerizing properties of Krishnamurti’s teachings–notwithstanding the apparent awakening and helpful qualities they have–one might not even be aware of it.

In the same way that Krishnamurti’s teachings can have a temporary beneficial effect upon certain individuals, a civilization based on his teachings might be successful in its first stages of growth.(27) But, in the end, if not propped up or saved by esoteric corrections and guidance, it will falter, break down and disintegrate. It will never have the chance to develop into a Golden Age, because it rejects the Wisdom Religion.(28) Parallel to this notion is the idea that an individual will find the opposite of enlightenment if he rejects the age-old path of graded initiations

Endnotes

  1. At the same time it is an undeniable fact that Theosophy and Krishnamurti have much in common. So much even that some Theosophists consider Krishnamurti’s teachings a modern expression of the ageless Wisdom Religion. In many respects both are also very close to Vedantism, especially the monist (Advaita) version. The likeness between Krishnamurti’s teachings and Vedantism, albeit Blavatsky’s understanding of it, will become hopefully clearer in endnotes 5 and 7, in which Blavatsky contrasts esoteric and exoteric interpretations of Vedanta. The esoteric interpretation is Theosophical and the exoteric interpretation is similar to Krishnamurti’s position. Endnote 10 contains the explicit remarks of a Master arguing that Krishnamurti is indeed teaching Advaita Vedanta. About the likeness between Theosophy and Advaita Vedanta, Blavatsky states that “in the Esoteric philosophy [i.e. Theosophy], which reconciles all these systems… the nearest exponent… is the Vedanta as expounded by the Advaita Vedantists.” H.P.Blavatsky, The Secret Doctrine (Los Angeles: The Theosophy Company, 1964), Vol. I, p. 55. For more of Blavatsky on Advaita see H.J. Spierenberg, The Vedanta Commentaries of H.P.Blavatsky (San Diego: Point Loma Publications, 1992), pp. 4-5. ↩
  2. “No single rung of the ladder leading to knowledge can be skipped. No personality [personal self or soul] can ever reach or bring itself into communication with Atmâ [divine self], except through Buddhi-Manas [higher self]…” H.P. Blavatsky, The Esoteric Writings of Helena Petrovna Blavatsky: A Synthesis of Science, Philosophy and Religion (Wheaton IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1980), p. 414. ↩
  3. “This idea of a gradual process, this idea of gradual psychological evolution of man is very gratifying… . This gradual concept, which psychologically is generally called evolution, seems to me utterly false.” J. Krishnamurti, The Collected Works of J. Krishnamurti (Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt, 1992), Vol. XVII, p. 67. ↩
  4. “Most of us do not want to know what we are. We invent the higher self, the supreme self, the atma, and all the innumerable ideas, to escape from the reality of what we are–the actual everyday, every-minute reality of what we are. And we do not know what we are from day by day, and on that we impose something which thought has bred as the atma, which tradition has handed over as the higher self.” J. Krishnamurti, The Collected Works of J. Krishnamurti (Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt, 1992), Vol. XIII, p. 151. ↩
  5. Blavatsky wrote: “There is a great difference between an Avatara and a Jivanmukti: one, as already stated, is an illusive appearance, Karma-less, and having never before incarnated; the other, the Jivanmukta, is one who obtains Nirvana by his individual merits. To this expression again an uncompromising, philosophical Vedantin would object. He might say that as the condition of the Avatara and the Jivanmukta are one and the same state, no amount of personal merit, in howsoever many incarnations, can lead its possessor to Nirvana. Nirvana, he would say is actionless; how then can any action lead to it? It is neither a result nor a cause, but an ever-present, eternal Is, as Nagasena defined it. Hence it can have no relation to, or concern with, action, merit, or demerit, since these are subject to Karma. All this is very true, but still to our mind there is an important difference between the two. An Avatara is; a Jivanmukta becomes one. If the state of the two is identical, not so are the causes which lead to it. An Avatara is a descent of a God into an illusive form; a Jivanmukta, who may have passed through numberless incarnations and may have accumulated merit in them, certainly does not become a Nirvani because of that merit, but only because of the Karma generated by it, which leads and guides him in the direction of the Guru who will initiate him into the mystery of Nirvana and who alone can help him reach his abode.” H.P.Blavatsky, The Secret Doctrine (Adyar, India: Theosophical Publishing House, 1938) Adyar Edition, Vol. V, p. 352. Or: Idem., Collected Writings (Wheaton IL: Theosophical Publishing House, 1985) Vol. XIV, p. 374. Or: Idem., The Esoteric Writings, pp. 293-294. ↩
  6. “I have told you frankly that Masters are unessential, that the idea of Masters is nothing more than a toy to the man who really seeks truth.” J. Krishnamurti, The Collected Works of J. Krishnamurti (Dubuque IA: Kendall/Hunt, 1991), Vol. I, p. 173. Krishnamurti himself wrote: “The core of Krishnamurti’s teaching is contained in the statement he made in 1929 when he said: ‘Truth is a pathless land.’ Man cannot come to it through any organization, through any creed, through any dogma, priest or ritual, not through any philosophic knowledge or psychological technique. He has to find it through the mirror of relationship, through the understanding of the contents of his mind, through observation and not through intellectual analysis or introspective dissection.” J. Krishnamurti, The Core of Krishnamurti’s Teaching (Ojai CA: Krishnamurti Foundation of America, n.d.). ↩
  7. Blavatsky wrote: “In order not to confuse the mind of the western student with the abstruse difficulties of Indian metaphysics, let him view the lower manas, or mind, as the personal ego [personal self] during the waking state, and as Antahkarana only during those moments when it aspires towards its higher Ego [higher self], and thus becomes the medium of communication between the two. It is for this reason called the ‘Path.’… Seeing that the faculty and function of Antahkarana is as necessary as the medium of the ear for hearing, or that of the eye for seeing; then so long as the feeling of ahamkâra, that is, of the personal “I” or selfishness [the synthetic self], is not entirely crushed out in man, and the lower mind not entirely merged into and become one with the higher Buddhi-Manas [higher self], it stands to reason that to destroy Atahkarana is like destroying a bridge over an impassable chasm; The traveler can never reach the goal on the other shore. And there lies the difference between the exoteric and the esoteric teaching. The former makes the Vedânta state that so long as mind (the lower) clings through Antahkarana to Spirit (Buddha-Manas) [higher self] it is impossible for it to acquire true Spiritual Wisdom, Jnyâna, and that this can only be attained by seeking to come en rapport with the Universal Soul (Atmâ) [the divine self]; that, in fact, it is by ignoring the higher Mind [higher self] altogether that one reaches Râja Yoga. We say it is not so. No single rung of the ladder leading to knowledge can be skipped. No personality can ever reach or bring itself into communication with Atmâ, except through Buddhi-Manas; to try to become a Jivanmukta or a Mahâtmâ, before one has become an adept or even a Naljor (a sinless man) is like trying to reach to Ceylon from India without crossing the sea. Therefore we are told that if we destroy Antahkarana before the personal [personal self] is absolutely under the control of the impersonal Ego [the higher self], we risk to lose the latter and be severed for ever from it, unless indeed we hasten to re-establish the communication by a supreme and final effort. It is only when we are indissolubly linked with the essence of the divine Mind [higher self] that we have to destroy Antahkarana.” H.P.Blavatsky, The Esoteric Writings, pp. 413-414. Krishnamurti’s teaching neatly corresponds to the exoteric position as presented here by Blavatsky, for he proposes to access directly the impersonal universal creative intelligence (Atma) by tossing out aspiration (Antahkarana) and denying the existence of the higher self (Buddhi-Manas). ↩
  8. Blavatsky warns: “Be it far from me the suspicion that any of the esoteric students have reached to any considerable point down the plane of spiritual descent. All the same I warn you to avoid taking the first step. You may not reach the bottom in this life or the next, but you may now generate causes which will insure you spiritual destruction in your third, fourth, fifth, or even some subsequent birth… Finally, keep ever in mind the consciousness that though you see no Master by your bedside, nor hear one audible whisper in the silence of the still night, yet the Holy Power is about you, the Holy Light is shining into your hour of spiritual need and aspirations, and it will be no fault of the MASTERS, or of their humble mouthpiece and servant, if through perversity or moral feebleness some of you cut yourselves off from these higher potencies, and step upon the declivity that leads to Avitchi [state of soulless-ness].” H.P.Blavatsky, The Esoteric Writings, p. 418. ↩
  9. Lord Maitreya: “Thus although Krishnamurti was right to emphasize the necessity for independent thought, he was wrong in assuming that everyone else, regardless of past Karma and present limitations, could instantly reach that point which he himself had only reached through lives of effort, and by the aid of those Cosmic Forces apportioned to him solely for his office as Herald of the New Age.” Lord Maitreya in David Anrias, Through the Eyes of the Masters: Meditations and Portraits (London: Routledge, 1932), p. 67. [Full text of Maitreya’s message on Krishnamurti at alpheus.org/html/source_materials/scott_anrias/maitreya_da.html] Any of the Masters quoted in these endnotes I believe to be genuine members of the Great White Brotherhood. ↩
  10. ‘Sir Thomas,’ an English Master said: “Also instead of giving forth the new Teaching so badly needed, he [Krishnamurti] escaped from the responsibilities of his office as prophet and teacher by reverting to a past incarnation, and an ancient philosophy of his own race [Advaita Vedantism] with which you are familiar, but which is useless for the Western World in the present cycle. But those to whom he speaks think they are receiving a new message, and as such it carries undue weight. The message he should have delivered, he has failed to deliver–or only partly delivered. Nothing about Art–no plans for the new sub-race–educational schemes dropped–and in place of all this: Advaita, a philosophy for chelas, and one of the most easily misunderstood paths to liberation… He who attempts to teach Advaita, and omits all Sanscrit terms, courts failure. Sanscrit words engender an occult vibration which is lost when translated. Western words not suitable to describe subjective states of consciousness, because their associations are mainly mundane… Another flaw in this pseudo-Advaita which Krishnamurti is giving out, is that he addresses the personality, the physical plane man [personal self], as if he were the Monad [divine self] or at least the Ego [higher self]. Of course the Monad, the Divine Spark, is the Absolute Existence-Knowledge-Bliss, and hence eternally free, but that doesn’t mean that the personality down here, immersed in endless- seeming Karmic difficulties, can share its consciousness, or even that of the Ego- -the link between the personality and the Monad.” ‘Sir Thomas,’ an English Master, in: His Pupil [Cyril Scott], The Initiate in the Dark Cycle (London: Routledge, 1932), pp. 136-139. [Full text of relevant chapter at alpheus.org/html/source_materials/krishnamurti/truth_about_k.html] ↩
  11. ‘Sir Thomas’ again: “Well did my Brother Koot Hoomi say that Krishnamurti had destroyed all the many stairways to God, while his own remains incomplete. Also being incomplete it may lead to dangers unforeseen by those who attempt to climb it. Danger Number One: Krishnamurti’s casting aside of time-honoured definitions and classifications leaves aspirant without true scale of values. Danger Number Two: climbing his particular staircase necessitates constant meditation, which in its turn necessitates constant protection from Guru–and Guru not allowed by Krishnamurti. Of course a moderate degree may be practiced in safety without a Guru, but long-continued meditation leads to states of consciousness and excursions on to other planes where the Master’s guidance is absolutely indispensable.” ‘Sir Thomas,’ in His Pupil, p. 138. ↩
  12. “Krishnamurti’s Advaitism, which is not to be confounded with the recognized form of that philosophy, will, I fear, lead his followers nowhere except perhaps to hypocrisy and self-delusion.” ‘Sir Thomas,’ in: His Pupil, p. 139. ↩
  13. Kuthumi dictated in 1975: “Today Krishnamurti, denounced by the Brotherhood, denounces the true teachers and the path of initiation, proclaiming that the individual needs only himself and that this is the only God there is. Leading thousands of youth in the direction of sophisticated disobedience to the God within [divine self], to Christ the inner mentor [higher self], and to the masters of the Brotherhood, this fallen one has been the instrument of a philosophy that is not and does not in any way represent the true teachings of the Great White Brotherhood.” [Relevant Paragraphs at alpheus.org/html/source_materials/krishnamurti/kh_on_k.html] Kuthumi, “An Exposé of False Teachings,” Pearls of Wisdom, Vol. XIX, no.5, p. 29. Copyright © 1976, Summit University Press, P.O. Box 5000, Corwin Springs, Montana 59030-5000. (406) 848-9891. Web site: http://www.tsl.org. ↩
  14. Hodson wrote: “Here are his words [Krishnamurti’s] on the subject: ‘When we understand profoundly the significance of our existence, of the process of ignorance and action, we will see what we call purpose has no significance. The mere search for the purpose of life covers up, detracts from the comprehension of oneself.’ That quotation is a perfect example of the closed circle of thought outside of which I for one find myself to be shut when endeavouring to comprehend these teachings… He seems to put the very goal itself as the first step towards its attainment.” Geoffrey Hodson, Krishnamurti and the Search for Light (Sydney: St.Alban Press, n.d.), pp. 12-13. [Full text at alpheus.org/html/source_materials/theosophy/hodson1.html] ↩
  15. “In him, singleness of purpose has developed into intolerance. Unique individuality has become a fetish, worship of which produces narrow-mindedness and causes him to display distinct signs of intellectual arrogance. He alone is right. Everyone else, from the Lord Buddha down to the latest teacher of the Law, is wrong, criminally wrong.” Ibid. p. 8. ↩
  16. Theosophist John Algeo correctly observes that Krishnamurti is “teaching ends without means.” John Algeo, review of Krishnamurti–Love and Freedom by Peter Michel in Quest Vol. 8, no. 3 (Autumn 1995), p. 86. ↩
  17. See Mary Lutyens, Krishnamurti: The Years of Awakening (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1975), for the story of Krishnamurti’s initiations and spiritual development. See Charles W. Leadbeater, The Masters and the Path (Adyar, India: Theosophical Publishing House, 1925) for a Theosophical understanding of the initiatory process. ↩
  18. “The Arhat initiation is the one in which the Master withdraws all guidance from his pupil, who may have to negotiate the most difficult problems without being allowed to ask any questions. He has to rely entirely on his own judgment, and if he makes mistakes, must bear the consequences. And so what did Krishnamurti do? Like the proverbial manservant who knows he is about to be given notice, he gave notice first. In other words, he cut himself adrift from the White Lodge, and repudiated all of us. And unfortunately he induced others far below him in spiritual evolution to do likewise.” ‘Sir Thomas,’ in: His Pupil, p. 139. ↩
  19. “I wish I could describe how I witnessed the ego [the synthetic self] being torn to pieces and being thrown to the winds… . The center of thinking dissolved into nothingness.” Vimala Thakar, On an Eternal Voyage (Ahmedabad, India: The New Order Book Co., 1969), pp. 46-47. ↩
  20. Vimala Thakar thought, and I think correctly, that her transformation had something to do with the healing-sessions with Krishnamurti. She wrote: “I have told you [Krishnamurti] about the invasion of a new awareness, irresistible and uncontrollable. I have told you how it has swept away everything. Now–this has something to do with the healing.” Thakar, p. 43. Krishnamurti on the contrary was quite sure that the two phenomena were not related. Apparently, when she published her autobiography against Krishnamurti’s wishes, he ended their friendship and later his biographers gave her the silent treatment. [This last statement is not fair, because it is not true. Pupul Jayakar did deal with the Krishnamurti-Vimala Thakar relationship in a 2- page segment in her 1986 Krishnamurti biography. She did not mention the end of their relationship though. See: Pupul Jayakar, Krishnamurti: A Biography (San Francisco: Harper & Row, 1986), pp. 204-206. (Added March 2004)] ↩
  21. See endnote 7. ↩
  22. “If with all its power and superiority, one cannot think for oneself, there can be no peace in the world.” J.Krishnamurti, The First and Last Freedom (New York: Harper & Brothers, 1954), p. 64. For this Krishnamurti received some compliments from the Masters: “He did good work in teaching people to use their own brain.” ‘Sir Thomas,’ in: His Pupil, p. 139. And: “Krishnamurti was right to emphasize the necessity for independent thought.” Lord Maitreya in: David Anrias, p. 67. ↩
  23. “One sees that there must be change in oneself–the more sensitive, the more alert and intelligent one is, the more one is aware that there must be a deep, abiding, living change.” J.Krishnamurti, The Awakening of Intelligence (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), p. 43. ↩
  24. “But when the mind seeks a timeless state which will go into action in order to destroy the [synthetic] self, is that not another form of experience which is strengthening the ‘me’[synthetic self]?… So, having projected this state of continuance in a timeless state as a spiritual entity, you have an experience; and such an experience only strengthens the self.” From chapter IX, “What is the Self,” in The First and Last Freedom, pp. 76-82. It is hard to find quotes by Krishnamurti, uncontaminated by his basic errors. In the previous quote, for example, Krishnamurti does not differentiate between aspirations of the soul, which are wholesome (see endnote 7 about the Antahkarana), and ambitions of the mind, which might be destructive depending on who or what principle directs the mind. This line of thought makes him throw out the baby (the soul) together with the bathwater (the synthetic self). ↩
  25. “We have learned now the power of propaganda and that is one of the greatest calamities that can happen: to use ideas as a means to transform man… Man is not important–systems, ideas, have become important. Man no longer has any significance. We can destroy millions of men as long as we produce a result and the result is justified by ideas… When the intellect has the upper hand in human life, it brings about an unprecedented crisis.” From “On the Present Crisis,” in The First and Last Freedom, pp. 145-146. ↩
  26. See endnote 7. ↩
  27. The whole Krishnamurti phenomenon might be one of world-historical significance. We might be observing the birth of a completely new, though flawed, religion and civilization based on Krishnamurti’s teachings, with its geographical center in India and its outposts in the West. For some interesting ideas about the rise and fall of civilizations see Arnold J. Toynbee, A Study of History (London: Oxford University Press, 1946). ↩
  28. H.P. Blavatsky had high hopes for the Judeo-Christian and Indic civilizations to transform themselves into a “heaven” in the 21st century with the aid of the Theosophical Society, led by a prophesied “torch-bearer of Truth,” expected in the last quarter of the 20th century. See her Conclusion, “The Future of the Theosophical Society,” in The Key to Theosophy (Pasadena CA: Theosophical University Press, 1995), pp. 304-307. Annie Besant defended her involvement with Krishnamurti by referring explicitly to Blavatsky’s view about the future mission of the Theosophical Society and the “torch-bearer of Truth.” She clearly believed Krishnamurti to be the vehicle for that expected teacher. She wrote in 1912 that the only difference between herself and Blavatsky regarding the coming of “the next great Teacher” was that “she put that event perhaps half a century later than I do. Which of us is right only time can show.” Annie Besant, “Freedom of Opinion in the T.S.,” letter to The Vâhan 21\8 (March 1912), p. 153. With the 20th century now drawing to a close; the world in a state of unparalleled crisis, the Theosophical Society only a minor agent of change and no sign of a “torch-bearer of Truth” connected with it, it behooves Theosophists to contemplate the texts quoted in this pamphlet and consider an alternative perception of the esoteric history of the 20th century. My own proposal is contained in a pamphlet, “The Masters and Their Emissaries: From H.P.B. to Guru Ma and Beyond,” in which is stated that the teachings of the Masters, which were originally planned to be given through Krishnamurti, were given through Guy and Edna Ballard in the 30s and 40s, through Geraldine Innocente in the 50s, through Mark and Elizabeth Prophet in the 50s till the 90s, and through Monroe and Carolyn Shearer from 1995 on. For an overview of a wide variety of other Theosophical views of Krishnamurti see “Krishnamurti and the World Teacher Project: Some Theosophical Perceptions.” ↩